Mr Redknapp
Striker
Think that's what they were going for, There was something about a book on psychology with Aiden so maybe she got curious about her behaviour and read up on it?...
I enjoyed it either way
Inside No.9
- Thread starter Howard the Duck
- Start date
I enjoyed it either way
L
Lexingtongue
Guest
Horses for course, of course, mate! Got to be honest, this series has been a disappointing one for me, bar the magician one which was brilliant.Think that's what they were going for, There was something about a book on psychology with Aiden so maybe she got curious about her behaviour and read up on it?...
I enjoyed it either way
Mr Redknapp
Striker
I will admit that it hasn't been as consistent this series, still have enjoyed every episode mate. Don't watch much regular tv it is a nice change.
Maybe this will be the last one?
L
Lexingtongue
Guest
Who knows? It's pretty popular so I doubt it.
errant
Striker
Pretty much sums up the last half hour for me, that was too clever for me after a couple of sherry’s...I'll have to watch it again, was on the drink yesterday and I honestly had no f***ing clue what was going on
I’ll second that... shame like.
Last edited:
D
Deleted member 6694
Guest
errant
Striker
Say it, it’s a day later now...Reminded me of a movie but I can't say the name of it as it will obviously spoil it!
D
Deleted member 6694
Guest
No, I mean I'd spoil the movie if someone hasn't seen it given the reason why I'd be recommending it.
Mr Redknapp
Striker
Don't know where i read it but i'm sure series 4 was supposed to be the last.
Fair to say... this episode has mixed reviews on the internet
Last edited:
Beau Peep
Winger
I had subtitles on as the baby was crying and it called the voice "Therapist" which I thought could be what was intended, but the episode is called "Thinking Out Loud" so I do think it's supposed to be her own realisation, maybe helped by therapy... a bit of artistic licence as to which is which.
Last edited:
L
Lexingtongue
Guest
See, that makes it even worse as it would point to her having some deep understanding of the condition she's suffering from. Is she two personalities at once in that scenario? I think the idea wouldn't work without an explanation at the end and there wasn't an effective way to shoehorn it in.
Any links? I'd like to see if people have the same problem I did as I can't find anyone else mentioning it! All I can find are the usual 5 star reviews on Den of Geek, etc.Don't know where i read it but i'm sure series 4 was supposed to be the last.
Fair to say... this episode has mixed reviews on the internet
Last edited by a moderator:
jacko100
Striker
interesting, I havent seen the episode yet but that film is basically and adaptation of agatha christies "and then there were none"
Mr Redknapp
Striker
Inside No 9, Thinking Out Loud, review: an unusually clumsy effort from TV's most inventive duo
Did you see it coming?
Inside No. 9 - BBC 2 - Page 142
I was gripped - I recorded it and watched it while I was getting ready for work this morning, and I ended up being late for work.
forums.digitalspy.com
L
Lexingtongue
Guest
Cheers, mate. It's good to see some critical analysis as all I'd seen so far was the usual effusive praise but I think you see that with most things on the Internet these days. It's good to see that I'm not the only one who has issues with the episode although I can't see anyone talking about the unusual explanation problem I've mentioned.Inside No 9, Thinking Out Loud, review: an unusually clumsy effort from TV's most inventive duo
Did you see it coming?www.telegraph.co.uk
Inside No. 9 - BBC 2 - Page 142
I was gripped - I recorded it and watched it while I was getting ready for work this morning, and I ended up being late for work.
Last edited by a moderator:
L
Lexingtongue
Guest
Do you think? I though there was some decidedly dicey acting and writing in that yesterday... Not to mention that type of story has been done to death already.
Boinger
Winger
I thought the acting was excellent Lex, especially Shearsmith. As for it being done to death, I realise there have been many dramas of this type, but personally the only time I've seen films/tv about split/duel personalities were Psycho & Shutter Island iirc.... Oh and Batman.
