McGeady

[1more]

Should Parkinson bring him back into the fold.

Theres no doubt hes a quality player and a match winner. Personally I would.

 

[Scootsie]

Sometimes players and managers just don’t see eye to eye.

He’ll never play for us again, imo.

 

[ebb]

Still most skilful and probably our best player

 

[HeroHurley]

Unfortunately I no longer see a future for him as long as Parkinson remains here. It's probably best to try and move him on, get a decent fee and reinvest his wages. Shame it's to end they way it is really as he is a very talented footballer. We'll always have the Wembley goal.

 

[__howdy__]

Won't play for us again under PP.

Best player under contract by a stretch.

 

[Father Jack Hackett]

Sometimes players and managers just don’t see eye to eye.

He’ll never play for us again, imo.

This, unfortunately

 

[Alisander thunders]

Our best player, probably the only one who would be usable at a higher level and should be on the pitch no matter what.

 

[Tasman]

Has to be moved on for the sake of the player and club

 

[b1gals]

Too attack minded for Parkinson.

 

[Lord Alfred]

Still most skilful and probably our best player

Arguably Maguire is as skilful but more productive than McGeady. A lot of Maguires play has end product whereas McGeady often runs down blind alleys.

 

[TopCat]

Seems as though he only wants to play for certain managers (Grayson/Ross) and acts up when he doesn't get his own way. If we really was a disruptive influence in the dressing room then it's better he moves on.

IF Parkinson can get his head right then I'd welcome him back with open arms - easily our best player

 

[1more]

I also think the rumours of him being a trouble maker is a load of shit. If you watch him on STID he seems a team player. Giving the ball to Grigg to take the pen, taking injections to get through games whilst playing with an injury

 

[chopsfc007]

Arguably Maguire is as skilful but more productive than McGeady. A lot of Maguires play has end product whereas McGeady often runs down blind alleys.

How did mcgeady get more goals then under Ross

 

[Mary Hinge]

Still most skilful and probably our best player

Aye mint at beating the full back 3 times

 

[only one rade prica]

Still most skilful and probably our best player

Using safc logic, he'll never play for us again. Why have quality when instead you can have cheap average rubbish?

 

[Lord Alfred]

How did mcgeady get more goals then under Ross

Because he's a good player too. Maguire has similar stats this season but with more assists than McGeady last season. I did say arguably mind......if you disagree that's fine.

 

[Tasman]

Had a average year this year, and when we did piss him off hardly set Charlton alight, too much risk in a 34 year old and both parties should come together for a mutual release end of championship...

 

[Kenna]

His age is also a big factor now 34 pushing 35 is pretty old for a winger even in this league

 

[cooky]

Seems as though he only wants to play for certain managers (Grayson/Ross) and acts up when he doesn't get his own way. If we really was a disruptive influence in the dressing room then it's better he moves on.

IF Parkinson can get his head right then I'd welcome him back with open arms - easily our best player

No doubt he’s our most talented individual player but you are right, seems to have a history of only fancying it when playing for a manager who basically lets him do what he wants. Grayson and ross both seem to have given him an easy ride and that’s what he seems to want.

 

[stevo]

Too old now ,and wages excessive for where we are at the moment.Shame.