For 2013 onward, you could probably go back and work through some of this thread. Might be a bit hit and miss though and there's 551 pages now.Virtually anything beyond metal
A little before 2011 (it came out in 2010), I'd suggest Anais Mitchell's Hadestown as an album worth listening to (it's a concept album about Orpheus' descent into the underworld that's now become a Tony Award winning musical, somewhat oddly).
This site has archives of best of year lists etc. on it:
Album of The Year - Music Reviews, Ratings, Charts, News
Might be worth hunting around on that. It's godawful to navigate though.