Beatles - White Album

[PhilSAFC]

Overrated

 

[jackpunch]

Overrated

Why?

 

[PhilSAFC]

Why?

why what?

 

[dcl0sc]

I love much of it but was interested to see if SMB thought its genius or f***ing drivel as it's quite odd occassionally

It's just loads of class songs flung together. As someone said chaos. Number 9 is shite, so I'll give you that one!

 

[jackpunch]

why what?

Dont be silly. Why do you think it's overrated

 

[dcl0sc]

Overrated

Anyone know what this fruitloop is on about?

 

[PhilSAFC]

Dont be silly. Why do you think it's overrated

I don’t think it’s that good.

 

[jackpunch]

I don’t think it’s that good.

Ok. But why...what songs are drivel. Some of them are The Beatles best in my opinion.

 

[GK]

One of the greatest albums and perhaps the best double album of all time.

 

[Daffy]

Overrated

Hasn't listened to it ^

 

[jackpunch]

One of the greatest albums and perhaps the best double album of all time.

I like it more as what could have the best single album of all time There's too many I simply struggle with.

 

[Daffy]

Genius - along with Revolver & Rubber Soul

 

[dcl0sc]

I don’t think it’s that good.

Your opinion is wrong! I feel you need to take a good look in the mirror! #prayforphillip

 

[jackpunch]

Genius - along with Revolver & Rubber Soul

Just about prefer Revolver but it's very close

 

[peachy]

One of the greatest albums and perhaps the best double album of all time.

Not listened to much music?

 

[What A Waster]

Revolver, Abbey Road, Rubber Soul, Help!, Sgt Pepper, Magical Mystery Tour, A Hard Days Night, maybe even Let It Be are all better Beatles albums than The Beatles. That doesn't mean The Beatles isn't a good album but its by no means one of the best of all time.

Edit. Beatles For Sale is great and just as good.

 

[knarfw]

Overall? Pretentious pap, I'd rather drag my balls over rusted barbed wire than listen to that album in it's entirety.

 

[Iceman97]

Overall? Pretentious pap, I'd rather drag my balls over rusted barbed wire than listen to that album in it's entirety.

You wouldn't though.

 

[Royal 8er]

Another thread by someone who has the musical knowledge of an invertebrate, denigrating a universally acclaimed album by arguably the most popular band of all time.
Only on smb

 

[jackpunch]

Another thread by someone who has the musical knowledge of an invertebrate, denigrating a universally acclaimed album by arguably the most popular band of all time.
Only on smb

Excellent.

Which school of music is your diploma from pal. Grade 8 Tuba, Euphonium. Played in Orchestras, Symphonic Wind Bands, Brass Bands for 38 years. Also play guitar and piano. If you want a serious debate on music how about you talk me through your knowledge of Shostakovich 11 or Berg's Violin Concerto or any of the other 20th century composers. I've studied serious music for 40 years mate and I could run rings round you when it comes to musical knowledge, so lets not be silly.

My post was asking for thoughts about it hence the query as to whether it's genius or selfindulgent pap. So instead of trying to be clever why not contribute your own thoughts about it.