• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state with some features missing, normal posting/reading should now be possible.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

Matty Young .


Here's the keeper situation from my POV

Roefs - No.1 next year if we keep him, undoubtedly.
Ellborg - No.2 next year
Patto - Sell, but not due to him not being good enough to be No.2. I think he is currently better than Ellborg but he can't go back to being a No.2 when his stock is reasonably high following good loan spell at Millwall.
Young - Championship loan
Cowan - A full year in U21s with a non league loan for 1-2 months at back end of season.
 
PTR said:
Getting POTY nominations in L2, then you'd think a Champ club would snap our hands off for him.
I don't even think its a massive jump - I thought he should have went L1 this season, and said so on here. He'd already proved he was good enough for L2, and some.
Click to expand...

Aye. Great to get championship next year. Think if he does though he might have to fight for the position which can go either way for a young lad but he has the ability to be a championship number one. Watched a lot of him this season including in person at salford
stevo said:
Correct,Patto is light years ahead of Elborg.
Click to expand...

He really isnt
 
Last edited:
me is back said:
Ellborg needs to adjust to the pace of the game and the press, but otherwise I’ve been pretty impressed so far. Certainly not fazed by a big occasion. I don’t get the criticism really beyond “he’s not as good as Roefs”.
Click to expand...

This is a good shout. It’s obvious that ellborg is completely out of depth with the pace of the game. He want to take two seconds more and is often exposed.
He will soon out that behind him as he grows to the game.
AndrewP said:
He's older and more experienced. I'm not sure Patto will have a better career though. Time will tell.

Patto didn't do much wrong for us.
Click to expand...

Pattison didn’t do much wrong, however, he didn’t win us points. In the championship keepers win team points.
He was replaced by a keeper who wins games by outstanding overall performances and we didn’t see that in patto consistently throughout the season hence why he is not currently with us.
He also wasn’t tested with a consistent back up. He put weight on during the season which was noticed by all. It appeared he became complacent.
Be interesting his next move. Wish him well though.
 
Last edited:
bowers2 said:
This is a good shout. It’s obvious that ellborg is completely out of depth with the pace of the game. He want to take two seconds more and is often exposed.
He will soon out that behind him as he grows to the game.


Pattison didn’t do much wrong, however, he didn’t win us points. In the championship keepers win team points.
He was replaced by a keeper who wins games by outstanding overall performances and we didn’t see that in patto consistently throughout the season hence why he is not currently with us.
He also wasn’t tested with a consistent back up. He put weight on during the season which was noticed by all. It appeared he became complacent.
Be interesting his next move. Wish him well though.
Click to expand...
Patto did make match winning saves. No better example than the playoff final. I’d go as far as to say that he’s capable of saves that none of the rest of them can match. The one against Ipswich the other week was genuinely astounding. However I think you nailed it that Roefs wins us points by being such a strong all-round keeper. He has very few weaknesses. For what we are now as a club it’s such an important foundation. Last thing on Patto, it’s not that he’s bad with ball at feet as he’s often tagged on here. He’s just overconfident in my view.

For Young, you have to imagine that next year is at least one year too early for his pal prospects. Means that losing Roefs in the summer would be extra awkward. Hopefully Ellborg makes a leap over the summer and at least functions as a solid bridge for a year or two.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: PTR
The Cabbage said:
Patto did make match winning saves. No better example than the playoff final. I’d go as far as to say that he’s capable of saves that none of the rest of them can match. The one against Ipswich the other week was genuinely astounding. However I think you nailed it that Roefs wins us points by being such a strong all-round keeper. He has very few weaknesses. For what we are now as a club it’s such an important foundation. Last thing on Patto, it’s not that he’s bad with ball at feet as he’s often tagged on here. He’s just overconfident in my view.

For Young, you have to imagine that next year is at least one year too early for his pal prospects. Means that losing Roefs in the summer would be extra awkward. Hopefully Ellborg makes a leap over the summer and at least functions as a solid bridge for a year or two.
Click to expand...
I think Patto might be able to get better too. Still young for a keeper
 
  • Like
Reactions: PTR
bowers2 said:
This is a good shout. It’s obvious that ellborg is completely out of depth with the pace of the game. He want to take two seconds more and is often exposed.
He will soon out that behind him as he grows to the game.


Pattison didn’t do much wrong, however, he didn’t win us points. In the championship keepers win team points.
He was replaced by a keeper who wins games by outstanding overall performances and we didn’t see that in patto consistently throughout the season hence why he is not currently with us.
He also wasn’t tested with a consistent back up. He put weight on during the season which was noticed by all. It appeared he became complacent.
Be interesting his next move. Wish him well though.
Click to expand...

He did win us points. He also won us the play off final. That save from Moore early in particular was ridiculous.

Theres negatives ro his game but not making world class reaction saves to win games is not one of them
 
Select coaches said:
People will deny it but some of our fans aren’t keen on a local lad done good. Roefs has been amazing for us, but at the start of the season I was quite happy for Patterson to be given a go.
Click to expand...

Hahaha wheres this came from that I dont like local lads doing good? No I dont like playing players who are clearly not ready for the PL just because theyre local lads, and therefore endangering the jobs of tens if not hundreds of staff members who also happen to be local lads and lasses.

I’m sorry but Patterson wasn’t even a top championship keeper, he needed to be replaced, his strength/speed coming for crosses was woeful and did actually cost us points, im sorry that your memory eludes you but im more than happy to bring video evidence. There’s nothing wrong with him having a championship career, but to just wantonly “give a go” to a player in the most competitive league in the world just because they’re a local lad is cloud cuckoo shit.

I’m sure in this hypothetical that if we got relegated, one of the lasses being sacked off thought “whey it doesnt matter yanar because Patto got given a go”
 
Elberg is a kid who no experience and a lot of potential.

Patto is a miles better option to play in goal at this moment in time.

There should be two options with Patto:

1) Stay and be second choice
2) Sell for a decent fee

Not sure the merit in loaning him out unless there was a an option or likelihood to make it permanent.
 
Fred said:
Here's the keeper situation from my POV

Roefs - No.1 next year if we keep him, undoubtedly.
Ellborg - No.2 next year
Patto - Sell, but not due to him not being good enough to be No.2. I think he is currently better than Ellborg but he can't go back to being a No.2 when his stock is reasonably high following good loan spell at Millwall.
Young - Championship loan
Cowan - A full year in U21s with a non league loan for 1-2 months at back end of season.
Click to expand...
Richardson
Allen
Cameron
 
Think I'll support the club on this one as they seem to rate elborg better than patto which is what I also think, don't get me wrong patto is a very good championship player but will never make it in the PL.
Elborg is the better keeper
 
NGPost said:
Think I'll support the club on this one as they seem to rate elborg better than patto which is what I also think, don't get me wrong patto is a very good championship player but will never make it in the PL.
Elborg is the better keeper
Click to expand...

I don’t think we have seen anywhere enough of Mellborg to make that judgement yet. He’s done reasonably well but hasn’t immediately stood out like Roefs in terms of ability.
 
Sea to Shining Sea said:
I don’t think we have seen anywhere enough of Mellborg to make that judgement yet. He’s done reasonably well but hasn’t immediately stood out like Roefs in terms of ability.
Click to expand...
Made some good saves and looks comfortable enough. Roefs looks absolutely outstanding tbf, which is why he's beinv linked to big clubs.and will have a better career overall.

I think Ellborg will also have a fine career and Patterson will be good enough for top end championship.

This thread is supposed to be about Matty Young thpugh.
 
me is back said:
Ellborg needs to adjust to the pace of the game and the press, but otherwise I’ve been pretty impressed so far. Certainly not fazed by a big occasion. I don’t get the criticism really beyond “he’s not as good as Roefs”.
Click to expand...
I swear the hardest job in football is to be the back up/ replacement to an outstanding player/ players.

A young keeper when we beat the mags at Al-Qiddīs Yaʿqūb park in one of his first games in English footy is actually canny impressive start when you think about it.

Actually thinking about it, his current away record in the prem is played 2 won 2, 1 clean sheet, at Leeds and the Saudis, many a player has crumbled in those circumstances
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top