You tot up the good vs the bad and it's obvious to all but the most partisan observer that Ashley has been bad for Newcastle United. He even admits it himself. It's only really Sunderland fans (and tedious wind up merchants) who rate him as anything but a negative for Newcastle United.
We used to be regulars in Europe, regulars in the top half, regularly progressing the domestic cups. Now we're regularly fighting relegation, twice succumbing to it, just 1 season in Europe, rarely getting past the first cup fixture. Plus, we're still in debt, still had no real investment in the club's youth system or training ground and still failing to make any waves on the commercial side of things.