• The forum upgrades are now largely complete.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

[3rd Test] England v Pakistan (Rose Bowl)

Status
Not open for further replies.
16 more runs in 4 (and a bit) matches, and with that you're saying one is under pressure and one isn't. What I said was that it was a great innings building on a solid series v the Windies, and it was. It's the first time since Sri Lanka 2018 that he's justified his place. Good on him.

Three weeks ago Burns got 147 runs in one match, something Buttler has never done. Not as a keeper, nor as a batsman in his 46 matches.

It's pretty funny that you brought up Buttler and compared him to Burns, and now you're claiming I'm 'comparing apples with oranges'. And it's even funnier that you seem to be focusing on the catches Burns dropped in the slips, but not the horrendous performance behind the stumps which required him and Woakes to rescue the game. Objective you say? :lol:

If Burns is still struggling in a few games time, then we'll talk.
He got 145 runs in one match & made 85 and then 70 and DNB in the second innings, all vs India, which is something Burns has never done.

Which just illustrates the point that you cannot be objective.

How many centuries has Burns got this summer, since that seems to be the yardstick we use to judge batsman on?

I compared Burns recent record to Buttler's as it is worse. As a specialist batsman you would expect the opposite.

It's clear, neither are being judged fairly.
About from Burns having scored 2 tons? Including 133 in the Ashes?
Didn't win either of those games.
 
Last edited:

He got 145 runs in one match & made 85 and then 70 and not batted in the second innings, all vs India, which is something Burns has never done.

Which just illustrates the point that you cannot be objective.

How many centuries has Burns got this summer, since that seems to be the yardstick we use to judge batsman on?

I compared Burns recent record to Buttler's as it is worse. As a specialist batsman you would expect the opposite.

It's clear, neither are being judged fairly.

Didn't win either of those games.
That’s a bizarre argument mate. by that logic Andy Flower was crap. And Shane Watson was world class

I agree that Burns needs scores. I also agree that Buttler is looking better. But I think you’re cherry picking your periods somewhat

off to bed, here is hoping for good weather tomorrow
 
He got 145 runs in one match & made 85 and then 70 and DNB in the second innings, all vs India, which is something Burns has never done.

Which just illustrates the point that you cannot be objective.

How many centuries has Burns got this summer, since that seems to be the yardstick we use to judge batsman on?

I compared Burns recent record to Buttler's as it is worse. As a specialist batsman you would expect the opposite.

It's clear, neither are being judged fairly.

You'd probably have to wait until Burns plays against India, to see how he does like. :lol:

You're off your tits chief, goodnight.
 
He got 145 runs in one match & made 85 and then 70 and DNB in the second innings, all vs India, which is something Burns has never done.

Burns has never played against India.

Like chunky says, you’re cherry picking your stats and periods of form.

Both players are at different stages of their international career, both players have very different roles in the side.

It’s a pointless argument.
 
That’s a bizarre argument mate. by that logic Andy Flower was crap. And Shane Watson was world class

I agree that Burns needs scores. I also agree that Buttler is looking better. But I think you’re cherry picking your periods somewhat

off to bed, here is hoping for good weather tomorrow
No idea what you mean on the first part, but glad we agree that Burns needs runs, hopefully we get them this Test.
Burns has never played against India.

Like chunky says, you’re cherry picking your stats and periods of form.

Both players are at different stages of their international career, both players have very different roles in the side.

It’s a pointless argument.
I'm aware of that, it's as daft an argument me saying Burns hasn't got runs against India when he hasn't played them as it is him saying Burns has got 147 runs in a game when Buttler hasn't, when he's come damn f***ing close (ie. 145, not to mention an 85 and a 70 plus 2 x DNB 2nd innings). They're both nonsense arguments is the point, perhaps it doesn't come across clearly.
 
Last edited:
Might not be around too much during this one lads. Mental health really knocking me for six so focussing on other things. Will be checking in here from time to time, and hoping Jos makes me look like an absolute mug.

Up the England!
 
Might not be around too much during this one lads. Mental health really knocking me for six so focussing on other things. Will be checking in here from time to time, and hoping Jos makes me look like an absolute mug.

Up the England!
Pm me if you need mate
 
Might not be around too much during this one lads. Mental health really knocking me for six so focussing on other things. Will be checking in here from time to time, and hoping Jos makes me look like an absolute mug.

Up the England!

Look after yersel mate. Always on the end on a PM if you need it.
 
Might not be around too much during this one lads. Mental health really knocking me for six so focussing on other things. Will be checking in here from time to time, and hoping Jos makes me look like an absolute mug.

Up the England!
Hope your alright mate. @TheRey
 
Might not be around too much during this one lads. Mental health really knocking me for six so focussing on other things. Will be checking in here from time to time, and hoping Jos makes me look like an absolute mug.

Up the England!

All the best chief. If you feel the need for a petty squabble over some inconsequential batting statistics to take your mind off things, you know where we are.
 
been petulant throughoit his career imo

Behave yourself. He's been one of the most popular characters in the England dressing room throughout his career with both players and management alike.

Cannit give a nearby weather update 'fraid. I'm back in Sunderland for the duration of the test and I'll be watching it with a few beers on the sofa in front of me moohasive telly.
 
Might not be around too much during this one lads. Mental health really knocking me for six so focussing on other things. Will be checking in here from time to time, and hoping Jos makes me look like an absolute mug.

Up the England!
Always remember that if needed there are plenty in the cricket forum ready to listen

best wishes
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top