• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on. Normal posting/reading should now be possible.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Will Grigg's on fire, signed!

Status
Not open for further replies.
beam1234 said:
Jordan Rhodes might be a decent comparison. He made a couple of interesting transfer decisions to keep developing rather than going for the money.
Click to expand...

Yes I think that is a pretty good comparison if i'm honest. Rhodes did have excellent movement and was an excellent one touch finisher.
 

leerik_canamole said:
You could also ask though why isn't he creating more chances for himself ? We rarely have less possession than our opponents, so why is Maja only having one or two chances per game?
Click to expand...
That is a valid point worth debating/considering but one which ultimately can’t be proven either way.

I’d say the way a lot of teams set up against us limits the frequency with which we create chances. His movement and ability to find space in the box makes me personally think that it’s not largely through a fault of his own. Having said that if we had someone that was more involved in the general play then perhaps it would stretch defences more and make it less comfortable for them. As I say, who knows.
 
rentaghost said:
Yes I think that is a pretty good comparison if i'm honest. Rhodes did have excellent movement and was an excellent one touch finisher.
Click to expand...
Maja isn't lightening but surely he's quicker than Rhodes? He's painfully slow

leerik_canamole said:
You could also ask though why isn't he creating more chances for himself ? We rarely have less possession than our opponents, so why is Maja only having one or two chances per game?



If I could like this twice I would, but I can't do have a second unofficial like . . . . Like
Click to expand...
He does create some chances for himself, its not like he doesn't do it.
 
Guinness Guzzler said:
Certainly not yet. Some are getting very carried away by a decent return for a good side in a shit league.

He's young, so that obviously counts in his favour as he might (although not all players do) keep developing. Purely on stats though I found the following

16/17 league one season, James Vaughan 24 goals in 37 (one every 1.54 games)

18/19 league one season Josh Maja 14 goals in 22 games (one every 1.57 games)

So basically he's currently doing what James Vaughan has done, a player utterly useless in the Championship. Tin hat on, if I had to choose I'd probably take 16/17 Vaughan ahead of 18/19 Maja because, in addition to his similar (slightly better) goal ratio, he has more of an all round game.

This isn't meant to be critical of Maja, but some very average players have done what he's doing thus far. He's not doing so well in a shit league that we can predict premier league success! For me he's better staying here, playing, developing his game and seeing how far he can go. His choice obviously but if he goes I doubt he'll make an immediate impact on a higher league so getting regular football might not be easy
Click to expand...
Goals per min is a better yardstick than goals per game.

Maja goal every 121 mins
Vaughan 128 mins

Maja doing better 10 and a half years younger than Vaughan.(albeit Vaughan was 2 years younger then, so 8 and half years)
 
Guinness Guzzler said:
I don't think he's a better player, I'm just highlighting that for all people go on about Maja's goalscoring, his record isn't actually any better at this level than a player who we all know was absolutely shite in the league above. Purely for this season the Vaughan from 16/17 would probably have done better, he scored just as often but actually has that bit of physicality and would offer more all round. Obviously due to his age and potential you'd rather have Maja, my point is simply that he has a lot to work on and I think some are overestimating how impressive his record is in an absolutely atrocious league
Click to expand...

Get what you're saying but only thing I'd say back is that we actually don't create that many chances for Maja (or in general)
 
Guinness Guzzler said:
Certainly not yet. Some are getting very carried away by a decent return for a good side in a shit league.

He's young, so that obviously counts in his favour as he might (although not all players do) keep developing. Purely on stats though I found the following

16/17 league one season, James Vaughan 24 goals in 37 (one every 1.54 games)

18/19 league one season Josh Maja 14 goals in 22 games (one every 1.57 games)

So basically he's currently doing what James Vaughan has done, a player utterly useless in the Championship. Tin hat on, if I had to choose I'd probably take 16/17 Vaughan ahead of 18/19 Maja because, in addition to his similar (slightly better) goal ratio, he has more of an all round game.

This isn't meant to be critical of Maja, but some very average players have done what he's doing thus far. He's not doing so well in a shit league that we can predict premier league success! For me he's better staying here, playing, developing his game and seeing how far he can go. His choice obviously but if he goes I doubt he'll make an immediate impact on a higher league so getting regular football might not be easy
Click to expand...
Apples and pears spring to mind.
 
vinegar hill said:
Apples and pears spring to mind.
Click to expand...

I know, just find it interesting that, for all we're impressed by his goal record, it's not actually that outstanding for this league and has been recently matched a pretty dreadful player like Vaughan who probably also contributed more aside from goals that season. Obviously want Maja to stay and hope he can progress but if he goes we're not exactly losing someone who is guaranteed to be a success in the league above
 
leerik_canamole said:
You could also ask though why isn't he creating more chances for himself ? We rarely have less possession than our opponents, so why is Maja only having one or two chances per game?



If I could like this twice I would, but I can't do have a second unofficial like . . . . Like
Click to expand...
A big part of it certainly early in the season was he was isolated and usually had two CB's for company.
 
Can people not just enjoy Maja for what he is? A good, young player doing very well for us. It's as if posters are purposely looking for holes in his game to vindicate the fact that we won't miss him when he leaves. It's so odd and has been repeated over the years, often in respect to our better players.
 
Guinness Guzzler said:
I know, just find it interesting that, for all we're impressed by his goal record, it's not actually that outstanding for this league and has been recently matched a pretty dreadful player like Vaughan who probably also contributed more aside from goals that season. Obviously want Maja to stay and hope he can progress but if he goes we're not exactly losing someone who is guaranteed to be a success in the league above
Click to expand...

He’s 10 years younger than Vaughan

It’s not about him being a guaranteed success it’s about having a long term vision and having players and a team who can Grow as a club

It’s absolutely vital we keep him
 
rentaghost said:
Great post - nobody really knows how players adapt to the higher standard but in my opinion Maja probably wont cut it. His movement and instinctive finishing isn't enough there are tons of players that have performed well with those attributes at that level but not had the pace and physicality to do it at the top level. At this moment he's slightly less proven than a Matty Fryatt. I cant think of a similar type of player to Maja that is successful at the top level? that said he would be a big blow to lose this season.
Click to expand...
Possibly Teddy Sherringham who did not build his game around pace and strength. Touch, movement and great finishing just like our boy Josh.
 
WildinHetton said:
Possibly Teddy Sherringham who did not build his game around pace and strength. Touch, movement and great finishing just like our boy Josh.
Click to expand...

To be honest I think Sheringham was a wonderful player but also very strong on the ball. He was a deep lying player though, really good in the air but as much a provider as a centre forward. I take your point about pace though.
 
rentaghost said:
To be honest I think Sheringham was a wonderful player but also very strong on the ball. He was a deep lying player though, really good in the air but as much a provider as a centre forward. I take your point about pace though.
Click to expand...

He wasn't a deep lying player in the early part of his career though, very much a goal poacher. Clinical, much like Maja has been this season.
 
gipetto said:
Can people not just enjoy Maja for what he is? A good, young player doing very well for us. It's as if posters are purposely looking for holes in his game to vindicate the fact that we won't miss him when he leaves. It's so odd and has been repeated over the years, often in respect to our better players.
Click to expand...
I don’t enjoy watching players who won’t be here next season (or in a few weeks) who are actively trying to leave the club while pretending they aren’t.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top