Stockton Mackem
Striker
He’s definitely the worst player we’ve got5, anyone who keeps picking Cattermole does not fill me with confidence.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
He’s definitely the worst player we’ve got5, anyone who keeps picking Cattermole does not fill me with confidence.
agreedYep. First thing to consider is that a lot of it is out with his control, I don't think any manager in the world would absolutely turn this lot around. How has he done? Well, I've got more confidence than I did with Grayson, he sounds intelligent and, overall, there has been a slight improvement even after losing our main striker. We've not dramatically improved though, but we certainly haven't got much worse. I think a 5 is absolutely fair at this stage, he's not done enough to warrant any more, but equally can't be totally blamed for us still looking poor
Yes he’s got a whole host to choose fromSix out of ten. Never chooses the best starting 11
Same. He left Wales with his stock high, and I still don't really understand why he chose us, but more than happy he did. No backing, a lot of players with little or no motivation, yet we're still in with a chance of getting out of this mess this season. Based on what he's had to work with, a solid 8 feels right8 for me.
Fair pointThe only time to judge him is the end of the season. If he keeps us up he'll deserve huge credit. He took the job when we all thought it was a choice between McCoist and Phil Brown!
He inherited a shambles of a squad littered with bad eggs, bad attitudes and rank average players.
He's had a bad run with injuries which has certainly contributed to him not being able to settle on his best side and our financial restrictions effectively made him wheel and deal in the transfer window with both hands and one leg tied behind his back.
If, with a combination of raw enthusiastic youth, average journeymen and remotivated has beens, he somehow keeps the good ship SAFC afloat this season, he deserves 10/10.
Or a donkey !!
Another apologist for a player who should be nowhere near the squad.
6 from me, he's had no help at all from the owner so is pissing in the wind, however he has made mistakes regarding picking players and systems...