One SAFC player from the past (in your lifetime) you'd put into todays team.

[Skylon]

A fit Jan kirtchoff best cdm midfielder we've had .

He would be perfect for us

 

[Scorpion]

He would be perfect for us

Exactly mate , he was a Rolls Royce of a player oozed class and quality.

 

[WanderedFar]

Any point in putting SKP in if he doesn't get service?

 

[Bangkok Blackcat]

Schwarz or Rae

 

[yossarian31]

Niall Quinn - no brainer

 

[me is back]

Can I have Stefan Schwarz as player and also head coach?

Not the best player we’ve ever had but Alex Rae would also fit well in this team

 

[Butcher's Coat]

Tony Towers

 

[red mackem]

Ross Stewart

 

[Skylon]

Any point in putting SKP in if he doesn't get service?

Yes. Dunno if you watched the game on Sunday, but Clarke played the ball across the goal a fair few times. I am sure if skp was playing, he'd have finished a couple.

 

[WanderedFar]

Yes. Dunno if you watched the game on Sunday, but Clarke played the ball across the goal a fair few times. I am sure if skp was playing, he'd have finished a couple.

Yeah I did but also saw Clarke running backwards and then sideways for 40 yards rather than passing it into the box.

 

[Skylon]

Yeah I did but also saw Clarke running backwards and then sideways for 40 yards rather than passing it into the box.

Eh? You've just said you saw Clarke putting it in the box

 

[WanderedFar]

Eh? You've just said you saw Clarke putting it in the box

I was saying I watched the game.

 

[Brian Griffin]

Adam Johnson would be happy round the younguns.

 

[Haswell Makem]

Niall Quinn

This for me and have Rusyn playing alongside, ton of goals later. Second shout would be big Kenwynne Jones.

 

[Skylon]

I was saying I watched the game.

Are you sure? When did Clarke keep running backwards and sideways? He done it a couple of times, but I thought he was very direct on Sunday. Do you think goals only come from putting the ball in the box? Our goal come from Clarke switching it to the edge of the box

 

[Toasted Mackem]

In my day, obviously apart from Quinn and Philiips... hmmmm... the most exciting Sunderland player I ever watched was Charlie Hurley, so I'd have to throw his name into the hat.

 

[PaulG]

So, we're 9 pages in and no-one thinks that Jordan Henderson could help this team? Or are we only basing it on how they played when they were with us?

 

[big winnie]

Who would it be? I don't think I've even come up with a solid answer myself but Don Hutchison wouldn't be a bad shout.

Charlie Hurley

 

[Summer Bee]

Lorik Cana, just for the sheer entertainment

 

[Boots]

Kenwyne would be very effective for this team. Offensively and at defensive set pieces. He was probably a bit more mobile than Quinny. I mean I know he'd frustrate the life out of us with his languid style and could have days when he couldn't give a fuck. but he was.some by in his day.

I'd still rather have Sir Niall but Kenwyne deserves to be in the conversation.