Newcastle bigger than Everton?


Status
Not open for further replies.
I always go on the hypothetical player on the transfer list. He has a choice of Everton or Newcastle now, same wages, same bonuses, same length of contract, same signing on fee. Who does he choose?

At the moment it would be Everton hands down.
 
That makes Huddersfield bigger than Spurs and us bigger than Man City, both which are way off the mark.

There's numerous factors you need to consider when determining the size of any particular football club, not just one.
Agree and other than crowd size Everton come out on top in every department.
 
I always think big club and successful club are two completely different things. Had we have won the title back in the days of KK I don't personally think that would have made us bigger, I think it would have made us more successful. Newcastle, Sunderland, Everton are all huge clubs that are unsuccessful in my opinion.

When they make these videos do they edit the normal people out. When ever a Newcastle fan or Sunderland fan gets interviewed outside the grounds they come across really poorly. You would think the reporter watches 50 people walk buy then says look at this nugget coming we'll get this one.
Nah they interview all 50 and get rid of the decent ones
 
Both middle of the road PL clubs who aren't really going anywhere. Mags have the fanbase and stadium, Everton have more trophies. Everton could have been a big club but they seemed to get left behind in the 1990s when Sky got involved and football suddenly became very popular.

They had a canny side in the 80s mind but that was 30 odd years ago.
If Everton had a bigger stadium they would fill it without question

I always think big club and successful club are two completely different things. Had we have won the title back in the days of KK I don't personally think that would have made us bigger, I think it would have made us more successful. Newcastle, Sunderland, Everton are all huge clubs that are unsuccessful in my opinion.

When they make these videos do they edit the normal people out. When ever a Newcastle fan or Sunderland fan gets interviewed outside the grounds they come across really poorly. You would think the reporter watches 50 people walk buy then says look at this nugget coming we'll get this one.
Totally agree
 
Last edited:
Probably not far off there like. (Obviously us and you the other way round though);)

Depending on who you support aye. Trying to be impartial I'd say over the last 30 years Newcastle has been bigger, but before that nowt between them really, maybe the league titles lean it Sunderland's way a bit more, but Newcastle's 3 FA cup wins of the 50s probably carried a lot more weight back then as the FA cup meant more.

The 8 before Newcastle and Sunderland I'd have as man united, Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea, Man City, Everton, Villa, Tottenham. Recent success and financial might plays a big part which is why Chelsea and Man City are bigger than Spurs, Villa and Everton
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top