• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on. Normal posting/reading should now be possible.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Geertruida


Scorer said:
He’s very versatile and undoubtedly a good player but he’s not a better RB than Mukiele, better CB than Alderete, LB than Reinildo or CM than Xhaka from what we’ve seen. Consequently it’s difficult to argue he should be a regular despite his quality.
Click to expand...
He’s the best player we’d have on the bench in a fully fit squad.
It’s about depth not just first 11. He’s better than Hume IMO.
 
Scorer said:
He’s very versatile and undoubtedly a good player but he’s not a better RB than Mukiele, better CB than Alderete, LB than Reinildo or CM than Xhaka from what we’ve seen. Consequently it’s difficult to argue he should be a regular despite his quality.
Click to expand...
Perhaps not, but my issue is the lack of rotation. Regis doesn't rotate enough, he sticks with the same team until he's forced into changing it. This isn't good for fitness, this isn't good for squad morale, and leaves squad players rusty for when they have to be called upon.

Xhaka is injured for the first time in years for a reason, he's played every minute, including cup.

Gerty should have started more in a rotation.
 
I get why he would want to to go there but he is leaving one beach for another so a bit pointless really. Hope we don’t leave ourselves too short when the window closes
 
LukeJH96 said:
We have versatile midfielders. All Sadiki, Diarra and Enzo can play the position. You sign a defensive midfielder to cover Xhaka for a short period and then once Xhaka returns they aren’t going to play.
Click to expand...

By that logic, why would a defender sign? Which position would a defender come into and play straight away?
 
SuperKevsLeftBoot said:
He’s the best player we’d have on the bench in a fully fit squad.
It’s about depth not just first 11. He’s better than Hume IMO.
Click to expand...
Absolutely but that’s not starting regularly and he’s good enough to either be doing that somewhere else or fulfill the same role somewhere like Liverpool. I doubt he’d be thinking differently about this opportunity even if he’d played more.
 
East Riding Mackem said:
we need a midfielder more than a defender - Xhaka injured & Neil gone.
Click to expand...
Cover for xhaka looks key ....
But so does over at the back ....
Geertruida offered coverage of both .... but finding another like him looks a stretch hence 2 players... but even that looks at stretch. The Geertruida situation feels like it may pre date west ham ...if it does just how far back have we known of the risks
 
The Situation said:
It's going to screw us now irrespective of if we bring someone in or not. He's missed West Ham and obviously will miss a game he absolutely would have been starting tomorrow night, because of this.

Geertruida covers 3 positions (RB, CB and CM). It's pretty much a certainty that the incoming isn't going to be able to do that to the level that he can.

Reports of "the club recognise the opportunity and won't stand in his way" indicate we're more far more concerned about not upsetting anyone than we should be.

If it was solely about not screwing ourselves, we'd have to told Liverpool and Leipzig that he's our player until the summer and to take a hike.
Click to expand...
fair point on these two games. But I'm sure that the club will still be happy to give a firm "no" if they can't get what they think they need. I will wait until the dust has settled before I get too upset about how the situation has been handled.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top