• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state with some features missing, normal posting/reading should now be possible.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

Eng vs India - First Test - 20th-24th June


Can’t believe some of the comments on here about the Smith and Brook dismissals. The only reason we are nearing parity is because of this hyper aggressive approach to batting.
If we batted like some on here seen to want us to we would probably have 100 less runs.
I just don’t get it.
No it isn’t. Yes, there is a risk and reward which has to be accepted. But. Smith trying to take on four fielders on the leg side to anything short it brain dead.
 
That's ok when they are taking on balls around middle or off stump. But they're trying to pull the balls which are 1 to 2 feet outside off
But there was a comment on the thread when Smith was dismissed saying getting to 75 behind would be a result, yet here we are, less than an hour later and we’re only 50 behind. They’re given the licence to have a real go and that’s why what we all thought was a losing position on day 1 has been turned into anything but.
 
I think there’s always frustration when you gift your wicket away, irrespective of how well or how aggressive you’re playing.

It’s rough with the smooth stuff, but I get both argument. On the face of it though, our entire middle order (I’m calling that 3-7) got themselves out.
If India fielded better and not overstepped last night, Brook would have long been gone. Ultimately cricket is a game of fine margins and you have to take advantage of what goes in your favour. Brook mainly managed to and has just timed that pull wrong. But we seem incapable of not taking the pull shot on when the field is set to it, and it often leads to our downfall. Something that needs a little work on imo
Lead under 50 and another ball jumps
 
Three comments in succession in BBC comments highlighting the shortcomings of Bazball.

The Brook wicket shows why England won't win the Ashes. Silly shots at pivotal moments by too many players. Brainless!
John
This is why Brook won’t emulate Root unless he tweaks his approach. So much ability and naturally free flowing but, just reign it in a little lad!
Anthony
England, all or nothing approach, can infuriate as much as it entertains. Needed Brook to be the last man standing.
 
Measured aggression is great. Positivity is great. Seeing a trap being set and falling for it so easily isn’t. These brainless shots that prey on vanity have to be reeled in. We have to learn very, very quickly. It’s just using your brain and not throwing away your hard-fought gains.
The ones that get out you don’t like the ones that go for 4 and 6 are ok.

Easy game from behind a computer
 
Measured aggression is great. Positivity is great. Seeing a trap being set and falling for it so easily isn’t. These brainless shots that prey on vanity have to be reeled in. We have to learn very, very quickly. It’s just using your brain and not throwing away your hard-fought gains.
I understand the point you’re making but disagree completely. Being this aggressive means that sometimes you are going to playing at a lot of balls the more traditional player would leave. But it puts enormous pressure on the bowlers who don’t know what to expect - look at what Brook just did to Siraj. I think there are real benefits in doing the things that are annoying so many on here.
 
Three comments in succession in BBC comments highlighting the shortcomings of Bazball.

The Brook wicket shows why England won't win the Ashes. Silly shots at pivotal moments by too many players. Brainless!
John
This is why Brook won’t emulate Root unless he tweaks his approach. So much ability and naturally free flowing but, just reign it in a little lad!
Anthony
England, all or nothing approach, can infuriate as much as it entertains. Needed Brook to be the last man standing.
To be fair the main reason we won't win the ashes is due to our bowling attack not being up to scratch
 
Last edited:
Back
Top