Do you really think the ECB have put them words in his mouth? You may or may not agree with what he said but I'm certain Root has plenty of self respect as to not put his name to a words cos he's been told to
-
The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state with some features missing, normal posting/reading should now be possible.
Please read this thread for more details.
New user registrations are currently disabled.
Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.
Joe Root calls for a reduction in county cricker
- Thread starter Aidan11
- Start date
Do you really think the ECB have put them words in his mouth? You may or may not agree with what he said but I'm certain Root has plenty of self respect as to not put his name to a words cos he's been told to
Voice of fair play
Striker
Especially with his record and probably our best batter ever.
It’s not as if he has to say the right thing to stay in the side and on the payroll.
Pretty safe to say his cricketing skills guarantees that.
Steak Pie
Striker
Really? Sportsman being briefed to say what their employers and sponsors want is one of the most basic PR techniques there is.
Joe Root is paid by the ECB and whichever 16.4 franchise he's been bought by.*
Tweet something like.......
*Has he been bought, or is he one of those non playing brand ambassadors for Scampi Fries or something? I don't know or care.
Voice of fair play
Striker
Yeah mean already very rich sportsman who are top of the tree, been told what to say, why would he do that when guaranteed his place and pay?
You don’t think it possible it’s his genuine view rightly or wrongly?
Or is everything just one big conspiracy or propaganda which seems to shine through in most of your posts
Last edited:
I think your talking absolutely shite tbh. This isn't a can you do me a favour and plug this product or tweet out your thanks to the fans rubbish. This is a fundamental change in English cricket we are talking about here. No way of earth have the ECB asked Root to put this opinion out there against his will. Haway man, you are way better than this paranoid shite mind
Steak Pie
Striker
I find it amazing people don't know the kind of things that are player's contracts regarding media commitments.
It might or might not be his actual opinion, who knows? Or cares? But he wouldn't and couldn't say anything else.
Voice of fair play
Striker
I get your point up to a point.
But there is a clear distinction surely between having media commitments in contracts and suggesting he has to say what he is told and when whether he agrees with it not?
Players of standing in the game as Joe Root one of England best ever cricketers is not going to disagree with something but say it anyway publicly.
What they going to do drop him??
Steak Pie
Striker
"Having space to recover, prepare and improve your game during the season is crucial and the creation of minimum standards to protect travel windows and player welfare is non-negotiable".
Yes, I'm sure Joe Root definitely came up with that sentence all by himself and it definitely wasn't written by the PR people.
Not pay him his media bonus.
Voice of fair play
Striker
And I am quite sure he would not say it publicly if he disagreed with it.
Doesn’t need too his reputation, pay and place in the team is already secured
So logical conclusion is he does agree with it.
Last edited:
Steak Pie
Striker
Tbh, I wouldn't have expected you to come to any other conclusion.
Voice of fair play
Striker
Same with you, as everything now according to your good self is one big conspiracy.
Nobody could possibly have a genuine view contrary to yours on what best for English cricket going forward.
Because anyone who does is apparently brainwashed or bribed by the devil themselves the ECB!
Or sorry forgot FTECB!
Last edited:
The relevant point is surely that Root is not a county cricketer,he's an ECB contracted England cricketer. He's,therefore,not qualified to comment on the workload of the county cricketer.
I don't think anyone is saying any thoughts on the subject have been polished up by someone. Any article a sportsman does in a paper is ghost written to an extent but it's mental to suggest he's been forced to put it on there when he may think something different
Steak Pie
Striker
What a thread.
Rather than actually discussing the points it’s the use of the word “bellend” and hyperbole about conspiracy theories and propaganda
Rather than actually discussing the points it’s the use of the word “bellend” and hyperbole about conspiracy theories and propaganda
Voice of fair play
Striker
Well yeah that’s certainly a fair point, but a very different one from a suggestion he just puts out publicly whatever he is told even if he fully disagrees with it.
Once again it seems on threads like these the actual debate of whether the workload too much which has merits on both sides is lost with name calling and suggestions of lying against one of our best cricketers ever who has a outstanding reputation imo,
You can blame the lunatics suggesting Roots been forced to put this out against his will for that. If Root argued the other way in this debate and VOFP suggested he'd been nobbled this place would have exploded with everyone attacking him
From what I’ve read, admittedly skimmed, I don’t think anyone has said forced have they? But he’s certainly conflicted
The outrage at a few nasty words thrown at him was the first thing that derailed the thread of course.
good article about the workload and who should have a voice on it.
You must be logged on to see external links
As to personal insults directed at Root, best ignored imo.
Apparently the ecb have drafted his opinion for him and and put it out there. Issues like that are easily fudged if needed. Fair enough be pissed off with his opinion, he's probably not best qualified having played next to no county cricket for years but no way he's been asked to put it out against his will
