• The forum upgrades are now largely complete.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

VAR has ruined top level football.


dangermows said:
No one agrees with you. Those against the call are saying its just off ("fanny's hair" etc) so shoulder been allowed as its too fine a margin. They aren't saying it's not offside.
Click to expand...

I agree with her.

I asked earlier if you've ever been inside a stadium when VAR has ruled out a goal. You ignored me.

Your opinion would change in an instant if you had so I'm guessing you haven't.

Bin it. Now.
 
viccarlton said:
Have we ever seen or heard of VAR declaring that the players are level, thus onside?
Click to expand...

Nope. The lines are always seperate which means every offside decision ever has either been on/off which is impossible.
Select coaches said:
Millimetres difference but nobody ever questions when the clip is paused.
Click to expand...

it comes down to a human pressing a button at an exact moment. Not possible.
 
Doberman said:
I agree with her.

I asked earlier if you've ever been inside a stadium when VAR has ruled out a goal. You ignored me.

Your opinion would change in an instant if you had so I'm guessing you haven't.

Bin it. Now.
Click to expand...
No you don't. You think its ridiculous to chalk it off just because a toe is just off (unless you also can't see on the pic where they've drawn the lines).

My opinion wouldn't change here as the debate is if he's offside or not. He is. Its proven. The debate is not whether games should be decided on slightest of margins. That's a different debate.
 
The VAR seeth :cool::lol:

Get used to it. It's not getting binned. They'll just say it proved he was offside. End of.
 
Last edited:
dangermows said:
No you don't. You think its ridiculous to chalk it off just because a toe is just off (unless you also can't see on the pic where they've drawn the lines).

My opinion wouldn't change here as the debate is if he's offside or not. He is. Its proven. The devate is not whether games should be decided on slightest of margins.
Click to expand...
You can never precisely tell when the ball is struck/leaves the players boot, so it isn't proven at all, roll on one frame onwards or backwards and it's a different outcome, you trust those operating the system that they don't make mistakes? That's been proven many times that they do, scrap it 💯
 
The only thing that is screwing the game up is money. Money gives power to the wealthiest clubs and they use it to remain dominant and to have an advantage in a "game". VAR is part of it.

Money is the root of it. The game is corrupt and has been for some time. There is no level playing field anymore.
 
This new system next season should be far better. Will take seconds and will get an actual display of why it’s offside.

How many times has goal line technology showed the ball has a tiny amount still on the line and therefore it’s not a goal? And yet there are very little complaints about that.

He offside and it doesn’t matter if it’s an inch or a yard. It’s not subjective so no clear and obvious. It’s like saying it should’t be hand ball if a player scores with his little finger as it only touched a small amount of his hand
 
MadMackem10 said:
This new system next season should be far better. Will take seconds and will get an actual display of why it’s offside.

How many times has goal line technology showed the ball has a tiny amount still on the line and therefore it’s not a goal? And yet there are very little complaints about that.

He offside and it doesn’t matter if it’s an inch or a yard. It’s not subjective so no clear and obvious. It’s like saying it should’t be hand ball if a player scores with his little finger as it only touched a small amount of his hand
Click to expand...
Nailed it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top