• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state with some features missing, normal posting/reading should now be possible.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

Boro thread

Georgewhitt said:
But you do claim to speak for the "vast majority"

Your post#2840

"But don't claim for a second it has the emotional element of a derby for the vast majority of our fanbase who live within 10 miles of the SOL."

You have nowt to base that statement on other than your opinion.
And what the fuck has living within 10 miles of The SOL got to do with anything? I've never lived within 10 miles of Roker Park or The SOL. Means fuck all man.
Click to expand...
Edit.....Just checked. Hetton is 8 miles, so I have. Still makes no difference as to whether it's a derby or not though.
 

wev17 said:
They also don't prove it isn't a derby.

Edit: Argh - why am I getting drawn into this, again. Whatever.
Click to expand...
We're all just speaking about our own experiences, I don't hate Boro at all. There must be something though because we don't have these arguments about Rotherham or Hull.

I think we have lost our traditional rival to the Saudi state like, so we are basically the same as you now in that way.
 
scott934 said:
We're all just speaking about our own experiences, I don't hate Boro at all. There must be something though because we don't have these arguments about Rotherham or Hull.

I think we have lost our traditional rival to the Saudi state like, so we are basically the same as you now in that way.
Click to expand...
Yip, the Newcastle we used to hate doesn't exist anymore.
 
wev17 said:
Honestly don't you want more games with an edge? Who wants games against southern clubs who bring no fans. Nothing better than a match day when the club brings fans and they are up for it.
Click to expand...
I like Boro in that they are a northern working class town, they travel well, seem passionate.
 
The Beautiful Game said:
Do you limit our tickets compared to others. Surprised at those stats tbh. I’ve moved to boro and felt more hate over football than I did when I lived in Newcastle
Click to expand...

Yeah it shocked me until I thought about it - Sunderland is one of our biggest games but there are other factors. You have boxing day games, end of season games, opening day games, quirky one off rivalry games that may get a big crowd. Then you have a Sunderland/Boro game that is nearly always on TV and the kick off time adjusted to prevent trouble.

But when you take all of that it into account and look closely, both clubs DO get a spike in their crowd when they play eachother. Take the latest game, 43.5k for a Sunday 12 o'clock game that's on TV. I don't see you getting that for a game against Hull at that time on TV.

Anyway, this has been done to death.
 
Georgewhitt said:
Edit.....Just checked. Hetton is 8 miles, so I have. Still makes no difference as to whether it's a derby or not though.
Click to expand...
The point was most people in and around 10 miles of the sol, where the vast majority of fans are from, don't have a strong emotional connection with Boro. Simply because they don't interact with Boro fans, so they aren't getting the piss ripped at school/college/work etc if they lose. In this area there is no day to day banter between Sunderland/Boro fans. As a result of this there is no strong dislike that you would normally associate with a derby match.

It's acknowledged Old timers like yourself will have strong feelings against Boro because of the fierce battles you describe off the pitch in the 80s.

Sunderland fans who live in the very south of Durham/teesside are naturally more likely to dislike Boro also, because they will have regular interactions with Boro fans. This raises the stakes of the fixture. There is "bragging rights" to be had in Peterlee or Billingham that aren't in Southwick or Shiney Row. So when you keep asking me about the 10 mile thing, this is why, because I acknowledge it's different further south.

Some fans feel it should be labelled a derby simply because of the distance, regardless of the lack of emotion for the majority of fans in the fixture.

So in a nutshell going through this thread, to some its a derby, to some it isn't. It depends on what criteria you use.
 
gatopreto said:
The point was most people in and around 10 miles of the sol, where the vast majority of fans are from, don't have a strong emotional connection with Boro. Simply because they don't interact with Boro fans, so they aren't getting the piss ripped at school/college/work etc if they lose. In this area there is no day to day banter between Sunderland/Boro fans. As a result of this there is no strong dislike that you would normally associate with a derby match.

It's acknowledged Old timers like yourself will have strong feelings against Boro because of the fierce battles you describe off the pitch in the 80s.

Sunderland fans who live in the very south of Durham/teesside are naturally more likely to dislike Boro also, because they will have regular interactions with Boro fans. This raises the stakes of the fixture. There is "bragging rights" to be had in Peterlee or Billingham that aren't in Southwick or Shiney Row. So when you keep asking me about the 10 mile thing, this is why, because I acknowledge it's different further south.

Some fans feel it should be labelled a derby simply because of the distance, regardless of the lack of emotion for the majority of fans in the fixture.

So in a nutshell going through this thread, to some its a derby, to some it isn't. It depends on what criteria you use.
Click to expand...
I take your point, but we didn't have day to day interaction with them back then either.

I think what you are doing is taking the feelings of hatred and loathing we have for the Barcodes and using that as a benchmark for what a derby should feel like.

I agree, that NO fixture will ever get my feelings racing, or my emotions heightened more than a game against that lot. It transcends hatred in my mind.

Nothing will ever match that.

But simply because Boro don't get my heckles up like that, does not mean it loses its status as a North East derby marra.
 
rentaghost said:
So you have said for the 873rd time :lol:

And we have had bigger attendances for Man U games than Mag games in the past. His point still stands - the Boro crowd is invariably higher than normal due to the locality and rivalry of the game.
Click to expand...
What rivalry 😄😄
gatopreto said:
Ahh don't mention that 4th goal. My phone went mad, full of Boro fans taking the mick. I was dreading going back to work that Monday morning seeing all the smoggies, they were going to rip me too bits. We'd been talking about the game all week.

When I got home from the game and got out my car my neighbour shouted out his window "4-0"

I walked into my local pub to drown my sorrows but it was full of Boro fans singing songs. One even put "Papas got a brand new pigpag" on the jukebox. I was that sick I downed my pint and walked out.

Sick of seeing all the boro shirts where I live, they've really came out the woodwork after ths.

None of the above happened. But if it did, that is what a derby game means.
Click to expand...
👍👍
 
Last edited:
I’ve never considered games against Boro as being Derbies.
Let’s say for example that neither us or Boro get out of the Championship in the next 20 years,could the games become derbies or can derbies for us only be against the mugs?
Extremely unlikely but if the Heed ended up in the same league as us and the mugs,would our games against the Heed become derby games,being our nearest opposition?
 
safctommie said:
I’ve never considered games against Boro as being Derbies.
Let’s say for example that neither us or Boro get out of the Championship in the next 20 years,could the games become derbies or can derbies for us only be against the mugs?
Extremely unlikely but if the Heed ended up in the same league as us and the mugs,would our games against the Heed become derby games,being our nearest opposition?
Click to expand...
Are you still pretending to support Sunderland?
And if so, why?
 
safctommie said:
I’ve never considered games against Boro as being Derbies.
Let’s say for example that neither us or Boro get out of the Championship in the next 20 years,could the games become derbies or can derbies for us only be against the mugs?
Extremely unlikely but if the Heed ended up in the same league as us and the mugs,would our games against the Heed become derby games,being our nearest opposition?
Click to expand...
Probably more edge because you'd have so many scum jumping on there bandwagon imo
 
safctommie said:
I’ve never considered games against Boro as being Derbies.
Let’s say for example that neither us or Boro get out of the Championship in the next 20 years,could the games become derbies or can derbies for us only be against the mugs?
Extremely unlikely but if the Heed ended up in the same league as us and the mugs,would our games against the Heed become derby games,being our nearest opposition?
Click to expand...
If Gateshead ended up in the championship i think it would be a sell out. By then they'd have a decent fanbase because of mags jumping on bandwagon.
 
There’s definitely a rivalry, without doubt, having said that I check the Boro results wanting them to get beat but not bothered really.
The Saudi lot I want to loose at everything, football, rugby, swimming, anything.
I’ve sat with the Boro fans at the riverside, but would never sit with them in St James.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top