MackemTackem
Midfield
Shame to lose you at SAFC but all the best Danny Batth at Norwich City!
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Based on what?Crackers decision, hope to God that Ballard and O'nien stay fit because the two young lads that we have signed look nowhere near ready to be starting games.
And?Player of the year last year
Would have been useful against Millwall etc but correct to let him go, given how we're trying to play at the back, rather than keep him as a sub.
Would have done more harm keeping him to have a section of the fans chanting his name every time we concede a goal.
Nothing more needs to be said reallyAnd?
Based on what?
Haven't seen anything of either of them.
Based on pre season and where they have came from, and Batth was voted player of the year by the fans based on his performances, just because you don't rate him doesn't mean that everybody that voted for him were wrong.Based on what?
Haven't seen anything of either of them.
Agree, it was last season and counts for nothing now. He was in poor form pre season and has been dropped on merit.Nothing more needs to be said really
Cos Tony prefers O'Nien and Ballard and rarely subs centre halves. His time will come.In the case of Triantis, why haven't we seen him?
The pre season when Baath was poor?Based on pre season and where they have came from, and Batth was voted player of the year by the fans based on his performances, just because you don't rate him doesn't mean that everybody that voted for him were wrong.
So competitive games only a few months back spanning over the course of a season count for nothing but a few meaningless friendlies based purely on gaining match fitness are the yardstick?Agree, it was last season and counts for nothing now. He was in poor form pre season and has been dropped on merit.
Cos Tony prefers O'Nien and Ballard and rarely subs centre halves. His time will come.
Baath was coming back from injury, its very narrow minded to judge him based on that, especially after the season he had.The pre season when Baath was poor?
Seelt barely played pre season.
I do rate him and would have preferred to keep him but he wanted to leave.Based on pre season and where they have came from, and Batth was voted player of the year by the fans based on his performances, just because you don't rate him doesn't mean that everybody that voted for him were wrong.
So competitive games only a few months back spanning over the course of a season count for nothing but a few meaningless friendlies based purely on gaining match fitness are the yardstick?
It's a very small sample size you're using to base your argument on. I'm basing mine on since when he joined but specifically last season, culminating in an individual award. We don't have to agree on whether he deserved it but the fact he got it speaks volumesBaath and Ballard both missed the end of the season. Both came back pre season, Ballard impressed Baath didn't.
I believe he was also poor in the league cup game but I wasn't there.
He wanted to play more games and the club couldn't guarantee him that, not my words but Speakmans, and again you are in the minority, most fans voted him as their player of the season.I do rate him and would have preferred to keep him but he wanted to leave.
I still don't believe he was anywhere near our player of the year, though.
He was excellent last season. His passing isn't the best but he wins more than his fair share in the air. He's a bit slow but is generally good positionally. He can be a little slow to close down at times.It's a very small sample size you're using to base your argument on. I'm basing mine on since when he joined but specifically last season, culminating in an individual reward. We don't have to agree on whether he deserved it but the fact he got it speaks volumes