FanchesterCity
Central Defender
I'd take milner again all day long.Harsh on Milner that mind. He's won the PL a few times, CL winner, youngest PL player/scorer at one point and dozens of England caps. Same with Phil Neville. I understand what you're saying they're not/weren't very influential players at the very highest level but they still had a big part play. Carragher won the CL and a quadruple with Liverpool in the early 2000s too iirc
I'd probably take Carragher too.
Phil Neville? lol