• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

3rd test team that you would pick for england

scotch

scotch

Striker
Realistic options (cook ain't coming back, Morgan won't captain, Stokes won't play)
Burns
Hameed
Vince
Root
Bairstow
Pope/Malan
Buttler (WK)
Ali
Robinson
Mahmood (if wood is out)
Anderson
 

There's no way we go into the next test with just 3 seamers and a part time spinner. Pope/Malan at 3 and another quick to come in.
 
Roy -- at least if he comes off he'll get us off to a fast start
Burns - least worst option
Root - might as well come in at 5-1 rather than a few minutes later at 12-2
Pope
Butler
Moeen
Robinson
Mahmood
Wood
Leech - done nothing wrong - dropped for all-rounders because top 6 can't do their job
Anderson
 
200 Miles Pilgrim said:
Roy -- at least if he comes off he'll get us off to a fast start
Burns - least worst option
Root - might as well come in at 5-1 rather than a few minutes later at 12-2
Pope
Butler
Moeen
Robinson
Mahmood
Wood
Leech - done nothing wrong - dropped for all-rounders because top 6 can't do their job
Anderson
Click to expand...
Bloody hell the state of this.
 
Burns
Hameed
Livingstone
Root
Bairstow
Buttler (WK)
Ali
Robinson
Mahmood
Wood / Garton
Anderson

Sibley and Curran out, Livingstone and Mahmood in. George Garton is my left field pick to replace Wood if he's injured, rapid lefty.
 
Steak Pie said:
Burns
Hameed
Livingstone
Root
Bairstow
Buttler (WK)
Ali
Robinson
Mahmood
Wood / Garton
Anderson

Sibley and Curran out, Livingstone and Mahmood in. George Garton is my left field pick to replace Wood if he's injured, rapid lefty.
Click to expand...

Would like to see Garton given a chance if the spot becomes available, he's looked good whenever I've seen him.

The team needs a few mentally strong winners, so Livingstone also not a bad shout.
 
PeteFTM said:
Would like to see Garton given a chance if the spot becomes available, he's looked good whenever I've seen him.

The team needs a few mentally strong winners, so Livingstone also not a bad shout.
Click to expand...
I agree on livingstone, we need to forget ability (no one has any anyway) and pick on personality and he’s about the strongest we have. Stoneman would be in a similar bracket.
 
TravellingMackem said:
I agree on livingstone, we need to forget ability (no one has any anyway) and pick on personality and he’s about the strongest we have. Stoneman would be in a similar bracket.
Click to expand...

The team’s mental weakness is a huge problem. They looked like they came out for the 2nd innings already defeated. The team needs a few winners in there to change that around

Morgan is a great example of that with the one day team, he never looks panicked or defeated.
 
TravellingMackem said:
I agree on livingstone, we need to forget ability (no one has any anyway) and pick on personality and he’s about the strongest we have. Stoneman would be in a similar bracket.
Click to expand...
When Stoneman got his chance I always felt he showed the right attitude and technique for test cricket, but just never managed to build a score and as a result went back out of the revolving door of partners for Cook at the time.

I would rather see him back in than to continue with Sibley, at least if he gets in he could then go through the gears and score some quick runs. It's surely no bigger gamble than any of the other options at the moment.
 
chelt_mackem said:
When Stoneman got his chance I always felt he showed the right attitude and technique for test cricket, but just never managed to build a score and as a result went back out of the revolving door of partners for Cook at the time.

I would rather see him back in than to continue with Sibley, at least if he gets in he could then go through the gears and score some quick runs. It's surely no bigger gamble than any of the other options at the moment.
Click to expand...
Stoneman had his chance and wasn’t great, I think there needs to be change but not sure he’s the answer. Also another left hander against this Indian attack probably isn’t the best idea
 
brandon said:
Burns
Hameed
Malan
Root
Bairstow
Ali
Buttler
Woakes (praying he’s fit)
Robinson
Wood (Mahmood if he’s not fit)
Anderson
Click to expand...
I would go for this team but with Overton at 8 assuming Woakes isnt fit and available. Hes not everyones cup of tea on here but I think he would make things difficult for them in the same way Robinson does and is a good bat.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top