Starting XI v Rotherham

[TravellingMackem]

Week in week out Grigg not good enough to start!

His miss today was shocking

Wether your playing RB or LB if your getting skinned by the winger your shite. Defending is defending. Stop the cross don’t get beat. He got battered by madderson at Peterborough

No he didn’t. Onien did - Maddison plays on the left, so would be up against our right back. And defending from the other side is massively different - means your tackling foot is different for a start.

 

[AC Mack]

His miss today was shocking


No he didn’t. Onien did - Maddison plays on the left, so would be up against our right back. And defending from the other side is massively different - means your tackling foot is different for a start.

Maddison generally plays more on the right.

 

[Mansfield Mackem]

His miss today was shocking


No he didn’t. Onien did - Maddison plays on the left, so would be up against our right back. And defending from the other side is massively different - means your tackling foot is different for a start.

You just said Maddison plays on the left so that means he was against o9. I saw Maddison beat Mc more than once at Peterborough. Mc is shite no wonder another championship team didn’t want to sign him on a free. You actually think he’s good?

 

[TravellingMackem]

Maddison generally plays more on the right.

Didn’t against us

You just said Maddison plays on the left so that means he was against o9. I saw Maddison beat Mc more than once at Peterborough. Mc is shite no wonder another championship team didn’t want to sign him on a free. You actually think he’s good?

I didn’t say he was good at all. I think he’s shite as well, but also it isn’t fair to criticise him for things that he wasn’t responsible for. I think Grigg is shit but I’m not going to blame him for Mcnultys bad touch in his one on one chance

 

[Quillips]

I'm in the minority but I don't like Wyke (as a player, not personally) and would prefer the front four we had today. He's much improved this season mind, so i can see why some have warmed to him. Just not my type of player. AM/CM/LG supporting MM gives us good balance I think.

I think Leadbitter gives us a calming influence that we lack when he's missing. Dobson alongside him is helpful in making us more attacking, first time pass to set CM away today for the third was great. All about opinions.

Disagree about Wyke, I'd be inclined to put him back in, make the opposition CBs work a lot harder. But if he has to wait, or come off the bench then he can have no complaints as it was his own fault getting suspended.

But agree about Grant. I think Leadbitter and Dobson are our best midfield combination. With McGeouch coming on if we need to hold on to possession more, or if Grant is tiring. And Power as cover.

 

[AC Mack]

Didn’t against us


I didn’t say he was good at all. I think he’s shite as well, but also it isn’t fair to criticise him for things that he wasn’t responsible for. I think Grigg is shit but I’m not going to blame him for Mcnultys bad touch in his one on one chance

He played on the right when he came on against us last season at home. He played on the right all game against us at their place last season. He predominantly cut in from the right first half against us a fortnight ago.

 

[Mansfield Mackem]

Didn’t against us


I didn’t say he was good at all. I think he’s shite as well, but also it isn’t fair to criticise him for things that he wasn’t responsible for. I think Grigg is shit but I’m not going to blame him for Mcnultys bad touch in his one on one chance

Ok jack Ross tells him to play on the left, but if he gets beat every time by the opposition winger it’s not his fault cause the manager said he’s playing LB. what a load of crap. He knows how to defend he gets beat every time

 

[TravellingMackem]

He played on the right when he came on against us last season at home. He played on the right all game against us at their place last season. He predominantly cut in from the right first half against us a fortnight ago.

I don’t care what he did last season. He played from the left last week. Even scored a goal from the left. Perhaps you should watch the games in future

Ok jack Ross tells him to play on the left, but if he gets beat every time by the opposition winger it’s not his fault cause the manager said he’s playing LB. what a load of crap. He knows how to defend he gets beat every time

It’s not really that simple though is it? You tackle with the opposite foot for starters. Your positional sense is entirely inverted and you cannot do the same things in possession as you are essentially backwards. If only things were that simplistic

 

[steve30000]

See how many Rotherham scored? Let's defend and hope for a draw!

 

[AC Mack]

I don’t care what he did last season. He played from the left last week. Even scored a goal from the left. Perhaps you should watch the games in future


It’s not really that simple though is it? You tackle with the opposite foot for starters. Your positional sense is entirely inverted and you cannot do the same things in possession as you are essentially backwards. If only things were that simplistic

Enjoy your meltdown, I don't really want to be part of it.

 

[TravellingMackem]

Enjoy your meltdown, I don't really want to be part of it.

What meltdown? This is how you react everytime you are shown to be wrong

 

[Mansfield Mackem]

I don’t care what he did last season. He played from the left last week. Even scored a goal from the left. Perhaps you should watch the games in future


It’s not really that simple though is it? You tackle with the opposite foot for starters. Your positional sense is entirely inverted and you cannot do the same things in possession as you are essentially backwards. If only things were that simplistic

It really is that simple. Stop the cross don’t get beat. He is shite. He gets paid a lot of money every week. So basically your saying he can only do his job if he is to the left of the white line.

 

[TravellingMackem]

It really is that simple. Stop the cross don’t get beat. He is shite. He gets paid a lot of money every week. So basically your saying he can only do his job if he is to the left of the white line.

Clearly you’ve never kicked a ball in your life then. More mistakes will happen playing on the wrong side. Many professional footballers would state this. But don’t let this block your deluded simplistic view of the world

 

[McGregor]

Wether your playing RB or LB if your getting skinned by the winger your shite. Defending is defending. Stop the cross don’t get beat. He got battered by madderson at Peterborough

I think maddison a stats suggest he skins the majority of full backs in this league.

You just said Maddison plays on the left so that means he was against o9. I saw Maddison beat Mc more than once at Peterborough. Mc is shite no wonder another championship team didn’t want to sign him on a free. You actually think he’s good?

I think he's a better full back than O Nien.. Id say he's our best RB but he's our only RB.

 

[Mansfield Mackem]

Clearly you’ve never kicked a ball in your life then. More mistakes will happen playing on the wrong side. Many professional footballers would state this. But don’t let this block your deluded simplistic view of the world

I used to play LB but could easily play RB being left footed. ConnerMc doest even make a tackle. Your sticking up for someone who has just been dropped after losing 3-0 and now we’ve won. Not saying it’s all his fault but he is crap

I think maddison a stats suggest he skins the majority of full backs in this league.


I think he's a better full back than O Nien.. Id say he's our best RB but he's our only RB.

He is shite

 

[Nelson!]

Disagree about Wyke, I'd be inclined to put him back in, make the opposition CBs work a lot harder. But if he has to wait, or come off the bench then he can have no complaints as it was his own fault getting suspended.

But agree about Grant. I think Leadbitter and Dobson are our best midfield combination. With McGeouch coming on if we need to hold on to possession more, or if Grant is tiring. And Power as cover.

I think we're too one dimensional when he plays. Just my opinion like and if he gets back in I won't be ranting and raving about it.

 

[marathon9]

Is xi a Chinese player what position will he start in..

 

[Mansfield Mackem]

I used to play LB but could easily play RB being left footed. ConnerMc doest even make a tackle. Your sticking up for someone who has just been dropped after losing 3-0 and now we’ve won. Not saying it’s all his fault but he is crap


He is shite

O9 isn’t event a RB and he’s better

 

[AC Mack]

What meltdown? This is how you react everytime you are shown to be wrong

I don't even know who you are, other than you having a meltdown the other week too.

Just watched the highlights on Sky Sports back - every single open play highlight involving Maddison shows him on the right and cutting in. Even for his goal that's exactly what he did.

 

[mart]

I think Dobson and McGeouch are comfortably our best midfield pairing and compliment eachother well. They should start until McGeouch gets injured.