• The forums will be unavailable for a few hours on Saturday 6th June, when they do return they will initially be in a degraded state with some features missing, but normal posting/reading will be possible. The main website will not be affected by these updates.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

Winning goal should have been disallowed

Status
Not open for further replies.

There was no offside for the 1st goal, and the 'foul' on Oviedo would have probably been soft. I'm not convinced of the freekick that led to the winner though, that was also very soft.
 
Evenly matched, if anything I'd say we were very marginally the better side. We definitely got less luck with decisions.
I wouldn't say we deserved to win but if the ref had made the correct decisions we would have however fortuitously.
 
I wouldn’t be surprised if some of the Championship clubs had a say in how this game went to be honest. Let’s face it who is going to be the bigger threat to them next season, us or little old Charlton?

Any Championship club would much rather have Charlton, Bransley and Luton up as cannon fodder than genuine title contenders like us.
 
MorpethMackem07 said:
I wouldn’t be surprised if some of the Championship clubs had a say in how this game went to be honest. Let’s face it who is going to be the bigger threat to them next season, us or little old Charlton?

Any Championship club would much rather have Charlton, Bransley and Luton up as cannon fodder than genuine title contenders like us.
Click to expand...
Shame they didn't care about little old Pompey in the semi-final...
 
What is p*ssing me off today, is that the people who weren't at the game who watched it on tv not just our fans are saying it was this and that's fault, yes some of the players and the manager should get some blame but being there the ref was a complete joke, Charltons tactics were to play act and hurt our players and the ref let them, you had to be there to experience how angry our fans were with the ref and Charlton players. It was a poor game both teams were poor but how many times are refs going to screw us over, lost count this season
 
MackemTackem said:
What is p*ssing me off today, is that the people who weren't at the game who watched it on tv not just our fans are saying it was this and that's fault, yes some of the players and the manager should get some blame but being there the ref was a complete joke, Charltons tactics were to play act and hurt our players and the ref let them, you had to be there to experience how angry our fans were with the ref and Charlton players. It was a poor game both teams were poor but how many times are refs going to screw us over, lost count this season
Click to expand...
How do you know who was at the game and who wasn't?
 
We were shite.
Charlton were average.
Average deserves to defeat shite. No problem.

By God, though, I want us to play better football than this next season. It was dross.
 
brisbanemackem said:
If Ozturk was a foul it was GBH on Oviedo
You must be logged on to see media items

You must be logged on to see media items
Click to expand...
Ozturk fouled him all day long yet some on here saying it wasn't a foul? :lol: Ozturk's left arm is round his waist and Ozturk's right arm over his shoulder so he gives the Charlton player an easy option to fall ower and get a foul. f***ing shite though as Oviedo had an arm on his shoulder so couldn't jump as high but his exaggerated fall didn't buy a free kick.

That still doesn't excuse the 22 seconds from the foul to the free kick being taken and still not being ready as the cross should never have come in with just 20 second left when play restarted!
 
Dodgy said:
First goal was offside. Not when the ball was played in but about three seconds before there were two players, (including the scorer), who were offside. Flag should have been up, there and then.
Click to expand...
Just watching it now...it looks like it was but Sky dont seem to be making much of it
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top