• The forum upgrades are now largely complete.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

2nd Test - England v India

Status
Not open for further replies.

OK, so what's the fall out of this one? Only Ballance and Root can escape criticism from that.

Robson - KEEP
Cook - DROP
Ballance - KEEP (AT 5)
Bell - KEEP (needs to step up)
Root - KEEP (AT 3)
Ali - DROP
Prior - DROP (FOR NOW)
Stokes - KEEP
Broad - KEEP
Plunkett - KEEP (UNITL END OF THE SERIES ONLY)
Anderson - KEEP FOR (NOW)

Replacements
Captain - ROOT
Opener - HALES
Keeper - BUTTLER
Bowlers - ANDERSON, BROAD, STOKES, PLUNKETT, BORTHWICK

Sorted for you, marra.
 
Ali doesn't offer enough to justify his place for me. If we're going with part time spin, is he any better than Root or Ballance?

Root for me, is a natural number 3 and Ballance is a natural number 5.
Not saying he's a match winner but offers good control and chips in with wickets. The fact is there is nobody who looks anywhere near a potential test match spinner in county cricket. Borthwick has hardly bowled this year so ridiculous to suggest him. Ballance has scored 2 hundreds at 3 and Root got runs at 5 so don't see why you'd change the order. Listening to Cook there he sounds like he's about to start crying, hope he steps down he looks shot.
 
How on earth can he say "Prior will play if he wants to" that is implying 2 things - neither of which are good for the England Team
also again said he was the best wicket keeper in England. Great for Buttler to hear from his potential captain just like Ali being called a part timer. Man management skills he has none, but KP could have told us that
 
also again said he was the best wicket keeper in England. Great for Buttler to hear from his potential captain just like Ali being called a part timer. Man management skills he has none, but KP could have told us that
he stated after buttlers 100 plus v sri lanka, he was not ready for tests.
 
by the way, has anyone mentioned that people receiving welfare have resulted in the decline of the england team?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top