• The forums will be unavailable for a few hours on Saturday 6th June, when they do return they will initially be in a degraded state with some features missing, but normal posting/reading will be possible. The main website will not be affected by these updates.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

Roy Maurice Keane

Status
Not open for further replies.

mackemal said:
Roy Keane struggled to deal with a Premier league squad who didn't meet his standards.

There is no way he would be interested in coming to a league 1 team with a squad that lacks any backbone or fight.

As much as I would love to see him come back he wouldn't last 2 minutes before he imploded
Click to expand...
I think he’s mellowed, I’m sure I’ve read a couple of articles about his self reflective years more recently and why that would make him a better manager. I’d certainly welcome him back
But are we not after Liam Manning anyway?
 
mackemal said:
Roy Keane struggled to deal with a Premier league squad who didn't meet his standards.

There is no way he would be interested in coming to a league 1 team with a squad that lacks any backbone or fight.

As much as I would love to see him come back he wouldn't last 2 minutes before he imploded
Click to expand...
He’d kill half of them in the first training session :lol:

I reckon he’d inspire the younger players
 
While it’s unlikely to be Keane, we need someone to grab us and drag us out this league

Smith, Reid, McCarthy, Keane, Allardyce. They all had something about them. We respond to that
 
I think we need that big personality that will bounce us out the divison, not one to call for those types of managers but i think its the only thing that will work.
 
I'd have him back if he fancied the challenge.

You don't need a tactical genius at this level and (as we're seeing already) talking football gibberish only ends up confusing players. Footy is a pretty simple game if you want it to be and Keane would no doubt tell the players to play it that way. He would also be massive box office again, like the first time round....I think we'd get a mostly positive reaction from the players too.

It all comes down to if he could fit within the structure which the club is being run. If he could just concentrate on his coaching duties and maybe bring in some decent backroom staff, I think it could work.
 
Mboma said:
I'd have him back if he fancied the challenge.

You don't need a tactical genius at this level and (as we're seeing already) talking football gibberish only ends up confusing players. Footy is a pretty simple game if you want it to be and Keane would no doubt tell the players to play it that way. He would also be massive box office again, like the first time round....I think we'd get a mostly positive reaction from the players too.

It all comes down to if he could fit within the structure which the club is being run. If he could just concentrate on his coaching duties and maybe bring in some decent backroom staff, I think it could work.
Click to expand...
Get him in.
 
0verlord44 said:
Coleman was not uninspiring like. The opposite in fact, but he played tactics that the team we had at the time had no idea how to execute.

seems the same with LJ like. Over complicated
Click to expand...

i always thought Coleman was more suited to International Management, he didn’t do much at club level at Coventry either. Some Managers are better suited… Giggs, Southgate etc.
 
0verlord44 said:
Coleman was not uninspiring like. The opposite in fact, but he played tactics that the team we had at the time had no idea how to execute.

seems the same with LJ like. Over complicated
Click to expand...
Couldn’t stand Coleman myself. Agree with you on the over complicated approach-this is Division 3 not Champions League.
 
hodge1973 said:
I think we need that big personality that will bounce us out the divison, not one to call for those types of managers but i think its the only thing that will work.
Click to expand...
This.

We have stagnated and have become part of the furniture down here.

Needs a character to drag us up and out of this shit pit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top