Rating Mince Pies

[Hawkings Boots]

I actually saw them in Aldi and wasn't sure they were worth the £2 after the shit of the lidl mini ones. Have got some of the Morrisons ones to try this week though. Their standard was decent but pastry was a bit dry

Mr Kipling - far from exceedingly good..

Dry pastry, crap filling - 3/10

 

[Deleted member 40035]

What happens to out of date pies?

 

[bigmarlon]

What happens to out of date pies?

They die.

 

[dafunk2]

I can confirm these are tremendous. I managed to limit myself to 2 last night. Same again tonight.

Logon or register to see this image

 

[Wilfy]

I can confirm these are tremendous. I managed to limit myself to 2 last night. Same again tonight.

Logon or register to see this image

I had some of the mini ones yesterday. Solid 8/10.

 

[Hawkings Boots]

I had some of the mini ones yesterday. Solid 8/10.

Had the Aldi Sloe Gin ones today

While not strictly a mince pie they are tremendous. Full 10/10

 

[Wilfy]

Had the Aldi Sloe Gin ones today

While not strictly a mince pie they are tremendous. Full 10/10

Added to the weekend shopping list.

 

[Venkman]

I know they're on the cheap, naff side...but the iced ones from ASDA are class.

 

[Hawkings Boots]

I know they're on the cheap, naff side...but the iced ones from ASDA are class.

They are a quality mince pie imo

The icing adds something different and they are cheap enough to hand round to visitors over Christmas

Solid 8/10

 

[MackemBob]

I know they're on the cheap, naff side...but the iced ones from ASDA are class.

We had them at the office today, along with m and s gold ones. Opinion was fairly evenly split as to which were the best.

 

[tunstall birdman]

Vile as fuck!!

 

[Hawkings Boots]

Morrisons 'the best'

Probably the best standard mince pie I've had this year tbh

9/10

 

[Wilfy]

Morrison’s fresh cream puff pastry mince pies. 11/10. Going to buy their full stock tomorrow.

 

[KingOfSeaburn]

The supermarket shortcrust ones are the best, Sainsbury’s in particular

 

[xr3i]

Them Aldi extra special ones are my favourites this year. Gone through a few boxes already this Xmas

 

[Deleted member 25315]

Vile as fuck!!

Thought you’d love burying your face into a sweet pie.

 

[tunstall birdman]

Thought you’d love burying your face into a sweet pie.

Got to be either a veggie one or a hairy mary.

 

[Mainze]

Make my own 10/10

Pastry
Vodka
Fruit
Caramel
White Chocolate

 

[Snappy]

Mince pies are f***ing shite

Absolute nonsense you balloon knot.

 

[LondonMackem]

Absolute nonsense you balloon knot.

Figured you’d like them you deviant