• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on. Normal posting/reading should now be possible.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Manager Rating Grid

P

Poon

Midfield
Seen this doing the rounds on Twitter amongst some other clubs and have to admit I struggled with a couple when thinking of the lads

Is my interpretation perfect or can anyone better it:


Good Manager​
Average Manager​
Bad Manager​
Fans Love​
Peter ReidRoy KeaneRicky Sbragia
Fans Divided​
Sam AllardyceMick MacJack Ross
Fans Hate​
David MoyesSteve BruceBeale

Rules:
1. No caretaker managers
2. Manager column is consensus in wider footballing landscape rather than how he did with us (e.g. Moyes was an abomination at Sunderland, but that doesn't make him a bad manager - West Ham success etc)
 

Assuming good manager means over their career and not at sunderland. Only explanation for Moyes being in that column!

Edit, just read the rules properly!
 
shieldsdan86 said:
Did Allardyce divide the fans? I thought everyone loved him when he was here or is that more about him leaving us? I don't hold that against him, you're always going to take the England job if it's offered to you
Click to expand...
One of the categories I struggled with tbh. I was factoring in the bung drama, but I do get that he is probably more liked than disliked
 
Poon said:
One of the categories I struggled with tbh. I was factoring in the bung drama, but I do get that he is probably more liked than disliked
Click to expand...
Maybe Martin O'Neill? I know there was a lot of contention around whether we should have sacked him or not and he did well initially but didn't hit the heights he's hit elsewhere.
 
Poon said:
Seen this doing the rounds on Twitter amongst some other clubs and have to admit I struggled with a couple when thinking of the lads

Is my interpretation perfect or can anyone better it:


Good Manager​
Average Manager​
Bad Manager​
Fans Love​
Sam AllardycePeter ReidRoy Keane
Fans Divided​
Martin O'NeillMick MacJack Ross
Fans Hate​
David MoyesSteve BruceBeale

Rules:
1. No caretaker managers
2. Manager column is consensus in wider footballing landscape rather than how he did with us (e.g. Moyes was an abomination at Sunderland, but that doesn't make him a bad manager - West Ham success etc)
Click to expand...
I'd say Allardyce (although I'm not his biggest fan) should probably be pushed up to fans loved, cos they did. And Ready was generally an average manager over his career. And Keane, whilst done well with us, was generally a poor manager.

I've adjusted mine in the quote cos I've no idea how to do the table myself.
 
shieldsdan86 said:
Did Allardyce divide the fans? I thought everyone loved him when he was here or is that more about him leaving us? I don't hold that against him, you're always going to take the England job if it's offered to you
Click to expand...

I was never sold to be honest, wrote checks the club couldn't cash.
 
shieldsdan86 said:
Did Allardyce divide the fans? I thought everyone loved him when he was here or is that more about him leaving us? I don't hold that against him, you're always going to take the England job if it's offered to you
Click to expand...
Stating everyone loved him is a pretty bold statement, I know of at least one person who knew all along he was/is a charlatan .
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top