1. The forums are temporarily closed for new registrations
    We expect to re-open for new users towards the end of July.
    Dismiss Notice

Changing prisons the way to stop re offending

Discussion in 'SMB' started by The Muffin Man, Jul 8, 2019.

  1. Imagine this ever getting past the gammons in this country. Even if the evidence is clear that spending the money to improve conditions, educate and properly rehabilitate inmates will have a massive impact on crime and improve all our lives, the British public simply wouldn't accept inmates being treated like human beings.

    How Norway turns criminals into good neighbours
     
    scott934, Fletch73 and daventry cat like this.
  2. Some Random Guy

    Some Random Guy Striker

    We, along with many countries, are too focused on the punitive effects of prison rather than rehabilitation and tackling the causes of crime.
     
    scott934, Struts, Fletch73 and 9 others like this.
  3. West_Winger

    West_Winger Winger

    That’s because politicians are too in thrall to the right wing press.
     
  4. This for me, prison serves 3 purposes, punishment, protecting the public and rehabilitation.....All are necessary but in the UK the one that will change our society and reduced re offending is completely ignored........Sadly we are further away from dealing with it than ever as anybody in power who sees that article will start banging on about Left liberal snowflakes and completely ignore the fact it works.

    Sadly this is 100% the reality. Imagine the outrage in the Daily Mail/Sun/Express if UK prisoners were given decent cells like that with Yoga classes and training.....They would literally explode and start banging on about pensioners in care and X soldiers not being treated as well as if there was some kind of connection between the two things.
     
    Last edited: Jul 8, 2019
    Fletch73, JohnSmithUK and Kent_Mackem like this.
  5. Some Random Guy

    Some Random Guy Striker

    Even without the right wing press, prison reform just isn't a vote winner.
     
    JohnSmithUK likes this.
  6. West_Winger

    West_Winger Winger

    It doesn’t stop a government from reforming them once in charge.
     
  7. Sadly I think you are right, which is a shame as the public want crime to fall and we know that a lot of UK crime is carried out by a very small number of people....Sometimes I wish people could see the bigger picture.
     
  8. Some Random Guy

    Some Random Guy Striker

    Thing is, can you justify getting Yoga instructors in for prisoners when your granny can't get a carer in from social services?

    "Tranquillity does not come cheaply. A place at Halden Prison costs about £98,000 per year. The average annual cost of a prison place in England in Wales is now about £40,000, or £59,000 in a Category A prison."

    Even as a left wing loon that understands the benefits of this I can't help but think that money could be better serves elsewhere.
     
  9. SPUFF

    SPUFF Striker

    How about this for some middle ground.

    Folk who constantly re-offend, put huge effort into rehabilitating them maybe over 2/3 sentences.

    If it appears its hopeless then they reoffend give them the chair, saving millions.:p:evil:
     
  10. girojim

    girojim Striker

    how much money is saved by a drop in re offending?
     
  11. Discopants91

    Discopants91 Striker

    We have the shittest of both worlds, don't rehabilitate people or make money from them like America.
     
  12. West_Winger

    West_Winger Winger

    It depends on results. If someone is released and goes on to cause more burglaries, robberies, drug abuse whereas if they were rehabilitated, got a job and paid tax then in purely financial terms the country is better off.

    Endless studies show that rehabilitation is better than punishment but none of the rags would stand it.
     
    The Muffin Man and daventry cat like this.
  13. Some Random Guy

    Some Random Guy Striker

    No idea off the top of my head, it would be cost effective though.
     
  14. Pop

    Pop Striker

    I agree with you and the article but as a victim of a violent crime most wouldn’t be happy seeing the offender being sent off for Yoga.

    The general public usually want blood.
     
    West_Winger likes this.
  15. SPUFF

    SPUFF Striker

    Would a trial be all that difficult. Ie change 1 prison for a decade then view the various results.
     
  16. Some Random Guy

    Some Random Guy Striker

    I know mate. If public services hadn't been raped over the last decade it would be an easier sell.
     
    sidneyeric and West_Winger like this.
  17. Grammar Police

    Grammar Police Midfield

    Our prisons are rammed with EU criminals rather than deporting the fuckers, who shouldn't have been allowed here in the first place.

    But let's all hail the wonderful 'four freedoms' our EU overlords have bestowed upon us.
     
    My Boy Harry and parm like this.
  18. West_Winger

    West_Winger Winger

    Jesus wept.

    Is this another one of those times when a brexiter ignores facts?

    Are our prisons "filling up with foreigners"?
     
    Last edited: Jul 8, 2019
    Keeping the Faith likes this.
  19. OOOSH YEAH

    OOOSH YEAH Midfield

    Would have been interested in this but the op used ‘gammons’ next post ‘snowflake’

    Thought ‘tit’ and can’t be arsed with it.
     
    Johnsafc, scott934, doobas and 3 others like this.
  20. sidneyeric

    sidneyeric Striker

    Stop jailing innocent people to save face would be a good place to start.
     

Share This Page