• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Jordan Henderson (signed for Brentford)

Church said:
This thread is really winding me up. Say we have a wages pot of £400k per week to use on new players, are we happy giving say £50k of that to a 34 year old player that not one other PL team thinks is good enough and has no resale value. I'd hope people would say they'd prefer that money goes towards a younger and fitter player, who can stay and grow with the squad.

All this nonsense about 'getting us' is daft. Players don't need to 'get us', they just need to be good.
Click to expand...

It’s the experience he brings to the whole squad. The winning mentality. I also think he’d be likely to come back on sensible wages. He wouldn’t rob us. He’s made for several lifetimes.
 

Montgomery73 said:
Jesus thats really small minded. Would you boo any player that goes to play in Saudi or just our own champions league winning captain? Do you watch boxing or formula one or do you turn it off if its in Saudi. I dont like the fact that they are seriously damaging sport especially football but definitely dont blame any individual sportsman who goes there. Thats just nuts
Click to expand...
I’ve never booed a SAFC player previously,his actions deserve protest.I agree sport is broken in general due to money.No respect or admiration can be given to anyone who takes dirty money,it’s not as if they are short of a bob or two before signing.
Let’s hope he doesn’t sign & my small mindedness doesn’t happen.
 
Morse said:
It's incredible how utterly, wilfully obtuse some people are still being whenever Henderson going to Saudi is discussed.
They persist with the same straw man argument that 'loads of people worked in Saudi', completely ignoring the entire reason why Jordan was widely condemned for doing so.

Some people just don't seem to get concepts like 'nuance', 'context' and 'hypocrisy'.

My personal view is that he sold his supposed principles down the river after building up a flawless reputation for himself. Silly boy.
If he came to SAFC, he'd have a mountain to climb to win back the respect he pissed away.

Maybe time will heal, but not everyone's going to forgive him.
Click to expand...

Hmmmm

At what point do you forgive and forget.

The mags have sold their souls to them. If all of a sudden there fans realised the error of there ways, and said nah fuck this, it wrong let’s move on, start a protest (they love that), and get these fuckers out, would you have more respect for them?

Hendo was very, very wrong for doing what he did at the time. That’s especially more so the case when prior to that move he was very much and advocate and ambassador for everything they stood for.

He paid for that mistake, he lost his England place, fell out of love with the game, and by all accounts hated it. He quickly realised his mistake, forgave a lot of money and moved on as quickly as he could.

At what point do we accept people make mistakes? Have you never made a mistake in your life? Are you saying that Henderson should pay for that for the rest of his life, or do we allow people to make mistakes?
 
I get the argument for not signing him, it was one I was fully behind. I'm fickle and a hypocrite as I'd sign him now
However the comparison in signing him and the mags being owned by the Saudis is beyond pathetic. One is signing a fella who went there to earn ridiculous money and ruin his legacy with it, the other is a whole club being owned by a regime who the worst of the worst the world has to offer. A fanbase who petitioned to be owned by them and celebrated the takeover like they'd won the Champions League, Fa Cup, Premier Leave and The Chase. That club cheered a bloke onto the field at the lopsided shit tip and at Wembley who was behind sanctioning the murder of a journalist

Please don't compare the situations
 
Morse said:
If he came to SAFC, he'd have a mountain to climb to win back the respect he pissed away
Click to expand...

I’m not sure about that. There will be many for whom it will not be an issue at all. There will be some that have issues that could be won over after good performances and a bedding in period. There will be some who will never forgive him no matter what he says or does. There will be a handful on here who bring it up every time he hits a pass or shot that goes astray.

Overall I think he would be welcomed back with open arms by the majority. Whether it’s a good idea to bring him back from a footballing perspective is another debate altogether where opinions will differ widely.
 
Church said:
This thread is really winding me up. Say we have a wages pot of £400k per week to use on new players, are we happy giving say £50k of that to a 34 year old player that not one other PL team thinks is good enough and has no resale value. I'd hope people would say they'd prefer that money goes towards a younger and fitter player, who can stay and grow with the squad.

All this nonsense about 'getting us' is daft. Players don't need to 'get us', they just need to be good.
Click to expand...
No mention of him still being a very very good player who would add to the side with his experience , quality and leadership. Sometimes you have to look beyond resale value and focus on the here and now
At this moment in time Jordan Henderson would be absolutely perfect for us going into a PL campaign with a ridiculously inexperienced squad.
 
It's a yes from me - we're crying out for some experience in midfield and he's still a top player. Free transfer, not huge wages and a 1-2 year contract and would definitely be a value for money signing. "The model" isn't all about signing 18 year olds, look at Danny Batth for example.

Couldn't care less about the Saudi stuff and neither would any player at the club or 99% of our support. We'd be adding a real leader to the dressing room and a great pro, no brainer IMO.
 
Rocky77 said:
No mention of him still being a very very good player who would add to the side with his experience , quality and leadership. Sometimes you have to look beyond resale value and focus on the here and now
At this moment in time Jordan Henderson would be absolutely perfect for us going into a PL campaign with a ridiculously inexperienced squad.
Click to expand...
This ffs...BHH!
Behind Enemy Lines said:
It's a yes from me - we're crying out for some experience in midfield and he's still a top player. Free transfer, not huge wages and a 1-2 year contract and would definitely be a value for money signing. "The model" isn't all about signing 18 year olds, look at Danny Batth for example.

Couldn't care less about the Saudi stuff and neither would any player at the club or 99% of our support. We'd be adding a real leader to the dressing room and a great pro, no brainer IMO.
Click to expand...
...and this
 
You know I think it’s great credit to our fans that this is a debate with people highlighting the moral issues of working for Saudi Arabia….

Meanwhile Newcastle fans stuck towels on their heads and jumped onboard like no tomorrow….

Pretty proud to follow Sunderland and for our fans to talk about and highlight how Saudi Arabia is a disgusting despotic nation. Rather than to worship them…
 
viccarlton said:
I’ve never made a patronising post ever, it seems to be you who is conflicted by the questions being asked here, wouldn’t want to get into a mud slinging argument with anyone, how about your “ grow up” comment, how patronising is that?
Click to expand...
Don’t comment on people’s moral compass when they don’t agree with you and you don’t know them.
 
Seems pretty clear he knows he made a mistake going there? Unless he's still bigging up Saudi this season, which I can't recall seeing. We're all human and people can make stupid mistakes but seemingly he abandoned the Saudi club as quick as he could and won't be going back.
There's no comparison to the mags who even now still love their saudi owners regardless of anything they do as long as they look to be close to winning things every season.

Ofcourse bringing him back depends on him, he would have to lower his wages a lot and maybe accept not starting every game, up to Regis that last part though.
 
Church said:
This thread is really winding me up. Say we have a wages pot of £400k per week to use on new players, are we happy giving say £50k of that to a 34 year old player that not one other PL team thinks is good enough and has no resale value. I'd hope people would say they'd prefer that money goes towards a younger and fitter player, who can stay and grow with the squad.

All this nonsense about 'getting us' is daft. Players don't need to 'get us', they just need to be good.
Click to expand...

He is literally in the bloody England squad like mate.
 
Diallo said:
If you look at my posting history you will see clear as day I am a lads fan. What I don’t agree with is people being hypocrites. It has also divided opinion on here which proves that.
Click to expand...
I reckon in every single football fans life they've been a hypocrite
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top