• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on. Normal posting/reading should now be possible.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Joe Gelhardt


Nathan Gunn said:
He gets a lot of unfair stick imo. Always grafted his arse off and was thrown into a shit situation. Plenty others would have done far worse
Click to expand...
Tin hat on but I thought he was alright playing out of position and grew into it. He was loaned as a number 10 but ultimately judged as a number 9 replacement (and our best one for years at that in Stewart.) Definitely a good player there.
 
Awful player at our level with no natural goal instinct at all. That goes for both Geldhart and Burstow.

Geldhart was our striker and when we came to cross I'd often see him wandering about on the edge of the box. Dreadful forward play.

Very shocked either them are still playing at Championship level.
 
Keith S30S said:
Awful player at our level with no natural goal instinct at all. That goes for both Geldhart and Burstow.

Geldhart was our striker and when we came to cross I'd often see him wandering about on the edge of the box. Dreadful forward play.

Very shocked either them are still playing at Championship level.
Click to expand...
Gelhardt wasn't brought in to be a striker, he was brought in to play off of/behind Stewart, but Stewart got injured pretty much straight after he was signed, then had to lead the line himself.
 
Billy Batts said:
Gelhardt wasn't brought in to be a striker, he was brought in to play off of/behind Stewart, but Stewart got injured pretty much straight after he was signed, then had to lead the line himself.
Click to expand...
Very few teams play 2 strikers. With Amad playing the 10 role and if Stewart had remained fit he would have barely played a minute then.

Any forward should have some ability and nouse. He had limited of the former and very little of the latter. He's just not good enough at Championship level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sid
Keith S30S said:
Very few few teams play 2 strikers. With Amad playing the 10 role and if Stewart had remained fit he would have barely played a minute then.

Any forward should have some ability and nouse. He had limited of the former and very little of the latter. He's just not good enough at Championship level.
Click to expand...
We had Stewart up front with Simms a few times before he went back to Everton.
 
Father Jack Hackett said:
To not be able to score goals with Amad and Clarke supplying you is some feat, when you look back at it
Click to expand...
Only needed a proper striker to play off supposedly.

He was a complete donkey. Even when he did get a chance he fluffed it but if Stewart was playing alongside him he’d have scored them. Load of shite
 
Keawyeds said:
Apps 15
Goals 2
Click to expand...
A marginal improvement from last season with us. I watched a Hull game the other week, well, more like Burstow watch. He's not changed at all, still doesn't run or challenge for the ball, bet the Hull fans aren't impressed with their new striker. Now they've got Gelhardt, he'll share the blame. They'll be lucky to get 10 goals between them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top