• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state with some features missing, normal posting/reading should now be possible.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

VARguments


bernardbresslaw said:
Missing 2 yards offside maybe, but not a toe when they can't definitively say when the ball was passed. And not that handball, which wasn't stopping a shot at goal, it was a cross FFS
Click to expand...
Yeah, hence I think it needs refining

The offside stuff: the semi automated thing works well (just as quick as looking at a linesman almost), but I’d build in a margin of error to get rid of the weird ones. That will be just as quick and be more accurate

The handball rule is the problem for me, rather than VAR. Needs sorting quickly

VAR as a concept needs some work. Sending the ref to the monitor is bollocks. If there is a significant miss (not a wrong decision, a miss) then the VAR overrules. Serious foul play and the like.
 
Hulkster said:
Denmark's disallowed goal Vs Germany.
Click to expand...

Was the offside not when he was an about a foot off side when the ball first went in ?
That still is the second time the ball went in but must have been the same passage of play as it’s all happened so quick and in such close proximity.
 
chunkyshanhawk53 said:
Yeah, hence I think it needs refining

The offside stuff: the semi automated thing works well (just as quick as looking at a linesman almost), but I’d build in a margin of error to get rid of the weird ones. That will be just as quick and be more accurate

The handball rule is the problem for me, rather than VAR. Needs sorting quickly

VAR as a concept needs some work. Sending the ref to the monitor is bollocks. If there is a significant miss (not a wrong decision, a miss) then the VAR overrules. Serious foul play and the like.
Click to expand...
Remember that it was supposed to step in when they'd been a clear and obvious error. Neither of these in this game have been that and supporters of VAR are saying this tournament is showing that it's now working. Not for me.
 
bernardbresslaw said:
But what is "getting it right" exactly?
I've already said I'd accept wrong decisions. Wrong decisions that we can see from the stands (not at home on the telly) I'd want and accept being overturned.
Click to expand...
Difficult question as a lot is subjective

Offside can be automated, that should say

But I think the actual rules need to be clearer. Every thread on here leads to a debate about decisions. And where it’s subjective, it stays on the field. Imo
of course
 
The offside is offside. It is much more black and white. There has to be a line drawn. If you say that's too tight, what happens when someone is a little bit further forwards than that? Are they now suddenly offside or do we say, we we let the other go so that's only just further so allow it? It's unfortunate but there will always be close calls. Atleast this way its consistent.
The hand ball however I can't agree with. Yes his arms out a bit, but when you run you use your arms naturally. He's a foot away from the ball and it flicks his finger. That's not handball to me and certainly not worthy of a free 1 on 1 chance from 12 yards
 
SAFC11 said:
The offside is offside. It is much more black and white. There has to be a line drawn. If you say that's too tight, what happens when someone is a little bit further forwards than that? Are they now suddenly offside or do we say, we we let the other go so that's only just further so allow it? It's unfortunate but there will always be close calls. Atleast this way its consistent.
The hand ball however I can't agree with. Yes his arms out a bit, but when you run you use your arms naturally. He's a foot away from the ball and it flicks his finger. That's not handball to me and certainly not worthy of a free 1 on 1 chance from 12 yards
Click to expand...
That’s an issue with the handball rule, not VAR
 
chunkyshanhawk53 said:
I don’t think it’s got it right tonight at all personally. I do think we as humans forget when it does however.
Click to expand...

It doesn’t

What’s the point

It’s all subjective.

It’s the worst thing in the history of the game

There’s no way you can say that’s offside it’s pure guess work
SAFC11 said:
The offside is offside. It is much more black and white. There has to be a line drawn. If you say that's too tight, what happens when someone is a little bit further forwards than that? Are they now suddenly offside or do we say, we we let the other go so that's only just further so allow it? It's unfortunate but there will always be close calls. Atleast this way its consistent.
The hand ball however I can't agree with. Yes his arms out a bit, but when you run you use your arms naturally. He's a foot away from the ball and it flicks his finger. That's not handball to me and certainly not worthy of a free 1 on 1 chance from 12 yards
Click to expand...

It’s not offside

There’s no way you can say that’s offside

It’s pure guess work at that level sorry
 
MustardAndOnions said:
It doesn’t

What’s the point

It’s all subjective.

It’s the worst thing in the history of the game

There’s no way you can say that’s offside it’s pure guess work


It’s not offside

There’s no way you can say that’s offside

It’s pure guess work at that level sorry
Click to expand...
It is and it's the same for everyone. Hand ball is far more down to interpretation and I really don't agree with that decision
 
SAFC11 said:
It is and it's the same for everyone. Hand ball is far more down to interpretation and I really don't agree with that decision
Click to expand...

I dont care if it’s the same for everyone, I’m not danish mate

There is absolutely no way you can say for sure that’s offside, you’ve spoilt the whole point of football which is to celebrate a goal, why has it be introduced

How Has that improved the game?
 
chunkyshanhawk53 said:
Offside isn’t subjective.
Click to expand...

Yea it is

That’s pure guess work

There’s no way you can say that’s definitely offside like chunky and you’re just lying if you say you can

No chance
chunkyshanhawk53 said:
It’s still absolute rather than subjective. Whether it’s the right balance or not is a different discussion of course
Click to expand...

It’s not at all tho. It’s a guess
 
SAFC11 said:
The offside is offside. It is much more black and white. There has to be a line drawn. If you say that's too tight, what happens when someone is a little bit further forwards than that? Are they now suddenly offside or do we say, we we let the other go so that's only just further so allow it? It's unfortunate but there will always be close calls. Atleast this way its consistent.
The hand ball however I can't agree with. Yes his arms out a bit, but when you run you use your arms naturally. He's a foot away from the ball and it flicks his finger. That's not handball to me and certainly not worthy of a free 1 on 1 chance from 12 yards
Click to expand...
When did the ball leave the passer's foot?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top