• The forums will be unavailable for a few hours on Saturday 6th June, when they do return they will initially be in a degraded state with some features missing, but normal posting/reading will be possible. The main website will not be affected by these updates.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

Test squad v Ireland


50% catch success off the pacers

You must be logged on to see media items
Ah, so we're also weakening our slips with this change rather than strengthening it, not like Steve Smith is decent with the bat or anything to give extra chances to
Crawley 13/26. Is there anything whatsoever to justify his selection ? Batting mediocre, slip catching 50/50

its getting more and more downright untenable
Just needs a pair in the test now
 
Ah, so we're also weakening our slips with this change rather than strengthening it, not like Steve Smith is decent with the bat or anything to give extra chances to

Just needs a pair in the test now
He was totally shot last summer with boult and Southee. They didn’t really celebrate getting him by the end. It’s beyond obvious that starc will bowl in swingers for lbw or bowled and hazlewood will just bang it down on fifth stump for the inevitable edge to second slip
 
I reckon I could do better than 50% :eek:


You aren’t willing to debate anyones posts that don’t agree with your own by the looks of things, that’s not cricket.

I made my points pretty clear mind. Bairstow n Brook are superstars in the middle order and should not be asked to open. Simple as that.

They left foakes out in Pakistan, I’m a bit mystified by the outrage.

Stokes picks the team, he’s in charge, he’s won 10 out of 12 , he knows what he’s doing.
It’s just my opinion, that’s all
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bri
I made my points pretty clear mind. Bairstow n Brook are superstars in the middle order and should not be asked to open. Simple as that.

They left foakes out in Pakistan, I’m a bit mystified by the outrage.

Stokes picks the team, he’s in charge, he’s won 10 out of 12 , he knows what he’s doing.
It’s just my opinion, that’s all

Ben Foakes is the best wicketkeeper in the world.

Team England told us that, not my words.

Why would you drop the best wicketkeeper in the world from your team?

Why also are you falsely equating this as either Bairstow or Foakes? Why is it one v one? Can’t they both be in the team?
 
I don’t know if Tim Murtagh is still involved at test level for Ireland but I can see him now steaming in at 75mph, gentle inswing taking out Crawley in the first session
 
Ben Foakes is the best wicketkeeper in the world.

Team England told us that, not my words.

Why would you drop the best wicketkeeper in the world from your team?

Why also are you falsely equating this as either Bairstow or Foakes? Why is it one v one? Can’t they both be in the team?

Unless you open with Foakes, no.

You seem to be trying to create tension, I didn’t pick team, stokes did. I’m simply agreeing with him.

ThAt 3 to 7 is world class, I’m more confident than ever we will win.
 
My other worry is stokes being injured and barely played a game in anger for months
Same for bairstow, who has had two 4 day matches and has seemed very slow and scrappy
Root barely batted for months
Harry Brook hasn't set the ipl alight a side from one 100 he has struggled.
Anderson older and picked up another niggle
Dan Lawrence seems to be distinctly average
Crawley below average
Also think we still struggle in the spinner department

Yeah and Australia are warming up for the Ashes with a Test in English conditions against India. We’re playing a glorified friendly against Ireland.
 
Bairstows mobility at the Riverside wasn’t great.
Feel sorry for Foakes. Crawley is a disgrace and I think Stokes’s knee is actually unfortunately career threatening and I think any contribution by him on the field will be severely limited
Hope I am wrong but not looking good imo.
 
Bairstow and Brook have to play in the middle order, therefor there is no room for Foakes. You can’t drop Root or Stokes. I don’t really get the controversy.

The controversy is Crawley has been shocking the best imo was to bring back Bairstow into the side keep Foakes and move another player up to open.

Bairstow had to come back in imo too good not too
 
Back
Top