Favourite all time SAFC XI

[Panhead]

Not best but favourite and year you started going. Go 4-4-2 with 7 subs 1xgk 2Df 2 Mf 2 Fw

First game 83

Norman
Kubicki
Scott
Bennett
Ball
Smith
Julio
Bracewell
Rae
Quinn
Goodman

Subs
Sorensen
Craddock
O’Nien
Hutchinson
Clark
Marco
Phillips

 

[Deleted member 41188]

Goodman over Phillips

 

[Whey]

Goodman over Phillips

OP does say favorites over best

 

[Deleted member 41188]

OP does say favorites over best

Aye but still. Haway man.

 

[look out piano]

Nee Stefan Schwartz either

 

[Be Here Now]

First game Sheffield United November 1995 won 2-0

Sorensen
Makin Thome Mensah (when fit) Gray
Summerbee Ball Hutchison Johnston
Quinn Phillips

Pickford
Craddock
Bould
Rae
Henderson
Bent
Defoe

 

[Panhead]

Aye but still. Haway man.

All about opinions mate. I met Don Goodman when I was 15 and he was a top bloke. Probably my all time favourite Sunderland player

 

[Deleted member 41188]

All about opinions mate. I met Don Goodman when I was 15 and he was a top bloke. Probably my all time favourite Sunderland player

Fair enough marra. I did enjoy him going toe to toe with Kasey Keller like.

But for me quality wise and favourite wise you can never deviate from Quinn and Phillips.

Absolute perfection.

 

[Farfrom Athletic]

Sorensen
Kubicki
Evans
Mensah
Arca
Roberts
Rae
Schwarz
Johnston
Diallo
Stewart

 

[davoak]

Mignolet makin bould Evans gray sumerbee ball Hutchison arca Quinn Phillips subs Sorenson Rae ord m Smith allan Johnson Ross Stewart

 

[Deleted member 21908]

Pickford

Whitehead
Evans
Brown
Arca

M’Vila
Schwarz

Edwards
Diallo
Johnston

Phillips

 

[chopsfc007]

Mignolet Bardsley Evans nyron, rose, ball,cattermole, Arca, steed, Phillips,bent

Pickford

Whitehead
Evans
Brown
Arca

M’Vila
Schwarz

Edwards
Diallo
Allan Johnson

Phillips

Swear your on constant wind up

 

[70s traveller]

Favourite XI: Monty - Dick - Joe B - Jeff Clarke - Shaun Elliot - Bobby Kerr - Bracewell - Arnott - Frank W - G.Rowell - Pop. For never to be forgotten displays, moments of class & the memories. Benno can be the sub cos in my time there was only one.

 

[socrates]

Given; Kay; Hurley; Watson; Bolton; Alan Johnston; Hutchinson; Schwarz; Baxter; Quinn; Phillips.

Subs. Sorensen; Ball; Rae; J Clarke; Gray; Rowell; Crossan.

First game 1963, home v Northampton got beat 2-0

 

[Railway Mackem]

Turner - Penna save from Roberts
Kay - canoeing on stretcher
Watson - oozed quality
Elliott - brilliant local lad
Bolton - favourite ever player
Kerr - FA Cup winning captain
Cana - mad
M’Vila - just as mad as Cana
Arca - Career ending challenge
Rowell - no words needed
Gabbiadini - lifted club from despair

 

[Whey]

Surprised someone hasn't listed Gary Rowell as all 11. Still time like

 

[The soap powder]

Norman

Bardsley
Ord
Ballard
Gray

Summerbee
Owers
Reyna
Johnston

Phillips
Gabbiadini

Hesford
Kay
Bennett
Armstrong
Defoe

 

[Cheesy Feet]

Given
Makin
Bolton
Hutchison
Watson
Bould
Summerbee
Schwarz
Quinn
Phillips
Johnston

 

[Rickybilly]

Monty
Irwin
Todd
Hurley
Bolton
Kerr
Ball
Baxter
Tueart
Martin
Phillips

Subs
Towers
Turner
Pickering
Quinn
Gabbadini
Watson
Venison
Rowell

 

[Heffer]

Sorensen
Makin Evans Mensah Gray
Summerbee Cattermole Malbranque Reid
Defoe Phillips

Subs: Mignolet, Nosworthy, Arca, Bardsley, Cana, Henderson, Sessegnon, Bent, Quinn