Has 'Chris Coleman' done a good job overall so far?

Status
Not open for further replies.


7

Was always going to be a work in progress. Has gotten a few clean sheets w/ some stability. Hands have been tied w/ this squad and incompetent goalkeeping.

He's made mistakes and will still need a little luck but he's gotten no help from short and it's going to be a slow climb upwards. Still confident he's the right man for the job.
 
ozcat said:
I’d give him an 8 because I’m not sure what else could’ve been done in his position.
Click to expand...

The only thing I wanted was a big fk off bully centre foreward !
Fk playing football, when you have a shit team you can compete by going direct ,

I’d give Coleman an 8 ,
Still amazed he took us on

hertsmackem said:
Not this again, who else can he pick? And do u think we would have come back from 3 down without him? Not a chance
Click to expand...

The same cattermole who was very good in the second half against Bristol City ,
you can’t just put a full team of kids on the pitch
 
7.5 for me. What he has done despite what he has inherited. Negative mentality throughout the club. Disenchanted fans. Disenchanted owner. Skint.

He has done a good job imo of starting to change the mentality by accepting where we are and in trying to build again positively from there. Fans have followed a bit and we are more in a mood of 'wonder' if we can just stay up. Under Moyes and his 'we're in a relegation battle' comments after a couple of games, I really feel put the entire club and city in a mood of 'resignation' and has contributed to where we have ended up - which CC is slowly dragging us out of despite the above. He needs credit for that and is a huge part of 'management'.

I will judge him more on the tactics and football side once he has a good set of cards to deal with. So far so good with what he has been left with. Getting the players out who don't want to be here is a good start on the road. Give him a team full of heart and we could have some good days under him imo.
 
He’s got to play four at the back for the rest of the season..if he does and we stay up.it’s an 8...if he doesnt we will go down and it’s a 5
 
8 or a 9, better than the last shite, working with one arm tied behind his back on account of the state the clubs in. Keep us up and he gets a 10, give him some budget in may and then judge him properly.
 
He’s only giving youth a chance because he has to. I have no doubt he’d fill the squad with shit like Robson Kanu, James Collins and the likes if he could.

A 3, hasn’t done anything special, a slight improvement on SG
 
7 - I'm amazed he hasn't flipped and walked out over some of the cowardly performances our players have put in during his tenure, doing his best with what he has and the fact we aren't adrift is amazing imo, hope he can keep us up and be allowed to build something we can be proud of again, though i'm sure he'll get tempted by better offers in the summer (or at least jobs that allow him to spend a bit of money!)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top