• The forums will be unavailable for a few hours on Saturday 6th June, when they do return they will initially be in a degraded state with some features missing, but normal posting/reading will be possible. The main website will not be affected by these updates.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Cattermol to Stoke....

Status
Not open for further replies.
£5million for Clattermole, whoooohooooo
Logon or register to see this image


He's had umpteen chances to prove himself a reliable consistent player who has learned from his mistakes ..... he hasn't learned from his mistakes, at all, he is a constant liability, just look at Southampton, picks up a lazy yellow on the halfway line and his game is fuct, can't play at 100%
 

BumbleBee said:
Poyets frustration regards Cattermoles lack of awareness at the weekend plus replacing him often recently suggests he is less than impressed.
Click to expand...
Basically Catts can't pass, the system dictates that the midfield passes...
 
Fireball07 said:
I'm not reading through the whole thread, is there a credible source?
Click to expand...

I'll summarize. There are no firm sources. We, as a community, have yet to reach consensus on whether it would be in the club's best interest to sell him, but we're working toward it.
 
If he's being sold purely to bring in the money for us to buy Bridcutt then it's a massively risky move by Gus. Yes, we all know he's got his limitations but he's comfortably in our best two central midfielders and IMO, fills an important role in Poyet's system.

Who knows what Bridcutt will be like at this level. Big risk IMO.
 
gipetto said:
Yes he can pass ffs

He's had some cracking games.
Click to expand...
He can't like, all players have some cracking games. Jeff Whitely did FFS.
He is a liability and doesn't fit in the system Gus wants, simple.
 
Scorer said:
Clearly amongst our three best midfielders and we play three midfielders. I would only entertain his sale if Bridcutt and another midfielder were coming in.
Click to expand...

Yep. As said, it's madness getting rid of any first-teamers in Jan and when we're 2nd from bottom.
 
Bit odd, actually. I don't consider Cattermole something to be held onto tightly. But at the same time, he is probably one of our best 11. Strange to hear that he is out before we know anything about a replacement. And as others have said, if the replacement is not up to it....

Colback is probably adequate as a stopgap, but I confess I was hoping for a midfield of Ki, Cattermole, and a new face. Looks more like Ki, new face, and Larsson is the combo we're looking at.

Are we still serious about Scocco? Maybe Ki, Bridcutt, Scocco as a midfield three?

Hard to read this one.
 
Murphy said:
I'll summarize. There are no firm sources. We, as a community, have yet to reach consensus on whether it would be in the club's best interest to sell him, but we're working toward it.
Click to expand...

Oh that's okay then.


Ideally, I'd like to keep him. We haven't been very good at replacing any of our other good players we've sold.
 
Provider said:
If he's being sold purely to bring in the money for us to buy Bridcutt then it's a massively risky move by Gus. Yes, we all know he's got his limitations but he's comfortably in our best two central midfielders and IMO, fills an important role in Poyet's system.

Who knows what Bridcutt will be like at this level. Big risk IMO.
Click to expand...
Means nothing.
 
hullmackem said:
He can't like, all players have some cracking games. Jeff Whitely did FFS.
He is a liability and doesn't fit in the system Gus wants, simple.
Click to expand...

Are you seriously comparing him to Whitley?

Sorry can't take what you say seriously after that. Cattermole has been one of our best players. He has been sent off once this season, hardly a liability! Plus it shouldn't have even been a sending off.

Bridcutt...no premiership experience. It's a massive risk. Yet again.
 
Hammie said:
Bit odd, actually. I don't consider Cattermole something to be held onto tightly. But at the same time, he is probably one of our best 11. Strange to hear that he is out before we know anything about a replacement. And as others have said, if the replacement is not up to it....

Colback is probably adequate as a stopgap, but I confess I was hoping for a midfield of Ki, Cattermole, and a new face. Looks more like Ki, new face, and Larsson is the combo we're looking at.

Are we still serious about Scocco? Maybe Ki, Bridcutt, Scocco as a midfield three?

Hard to read this one.
Click to expand...

Scocco is an attacking player... striker/winger. Giaccherini is a lot more likely to play there than him, considering he's played there for Juventus.
 
Hammie said:
Bit odd, actually. I don't consider Cattermole something to be held onto tightly. But at the same time, he is probably one of our best 11. Strange to hear that he is out before we know anything about a replacement. And as others have said, if the replacement is not up to it....

Colback is probably adequate as a stopgap, but I confess I was hoping for a midfield of Ki, Cattermole, and a new face. Looks more like Ki, new face, and Larsson is the combo we're looking at.

Are we still serious about Scocco? Maybe Ki, Bridcutt, Scocco as a midfield three?

Hard to read this one.
Click to expand...
scocco is not a cm
 
No
gipetto said:
Are you seriously comparing him to Whitley?

Sorry can't take what you say seriously after that. Cattermole has been one of our best players. He has been sent off once this season, hardly a liability! Plus it shouldn't have even been a sending off.

Bridcutt...no premiership experience. It's a massive risk. Yet again.
Click to expand...
No not comparing him at all, he is better then Whitely. Though IMHO he isn't a good player, I've seen him have more crap games than good.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top