• The forums will be unavailable for a few hours on Saturday 6th June, when they do return they will initially be in a degraded state with some features missing, but normal posting/reading will be possible. The main website will not be affected by these updates.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

Cattermol to Stoke....

Status
Not open for further replies.

johnson said:
You obviously haven't been watching the away games I notice

I think he's on, but to say you would rather have Ba playing us demented, and the sign that you clearly don't have the best interests of the team at heart
Click to expand...
Wrong on virtually everything in the post. Very strange questioning someones loyalty because he has an oppinion by the way. I dont rate him, sorry it upsets you so much.
 
ir35 said:
Wrong on virtually everything in the post. Very strange questioning someones loyalty because he has an oppinion by the way. I dont rate him, sorry it upsets you so much.
Click to expand...

Answer me two things or you have failed miserably

Can you honestly say he hasn't been good in our last 5 away games?

You would honestly rather play Ba in a premier league relegation fight.

Answer me them, if you really think that you are absolutely mental
 
johnson said:
He'd be the first idiot slagging them on Poyet off for not being good enough
Click to expand...

Cattermole as iv'e said on here numerous times, is one of the least of our problems in regard to putting names on the team sheet! I'd rather Poyet replaced our fringe players with one or two quality players, than selling a first team player and replacing him with an unknown quantity. We may not get much money for our deadwood, but ffs it's common sense given where we are to not sell first teamers!
 
IrishMackem88 said:
Cattermole as iv'e said on here numerous times, is one of the least of our problems in regard to putting names on the team sheet! I'd rather Poyet replaced our fringe players with one or two quality players, than selling a first team player and replacing him with an unknown quantity. We may not get much money for our deadwood, but ffs it's common sense given where we are to not sell first teamers!
Click to expand...

Exactly!

The same posters welcoming this will be the ones moaning when Gardner is playing!
 
My opinion is we shouldn't be looking to sell however 5 mil is a big offer, id probably say we should sell and sign Bridcutt and another such as Scocco to improve our attacking options.
I really do like Catts however he has lost a bit of pace which means he has lost his mobility so can't play CM anymore and can only play DM which is very limiting if we want to go to 4-4-2
 
Crammy Mackem said:
You say he isn't a Premier League footballer, remind me how many games he's played outside of it?

Yes he has a dodgy temper but he also provides us with a lot of cover, can be a decent passer of the ball, a good organiser and genuinely looks like he cares.

There should be no way he should be out of the door before Larsson or Gardner. I've been assured Bridcutt is very keen to come here but it's a big ask for him to step up straight away.
Click to expand...
Again, its my oppinion , I personally believe he's a terrible passer of the ball and a liabillity. He costs us as many points as he helps achieve. The fact hes not played outside the Premier league means nowt.
 
mr-bungle said:
Cattermole is never going to fit into poyets style of play. He is not technically good enough, nor has a fast enough brain, or capable of keeping possession of the ball under pressure. He panics under pressure and needs far too much time on the ball. We have all seen this on many occasion this season. He struggles in tight situations, and half of the time it is his own fault for getting into them as he isn't quick enough or have the vision to make the correct pass.
Click to expand...

I don't disagree with all of that but he's still the least of our problems currently. Sell him in summer maybe but it's a ridiculous decision now. Be one injury away from Gardner starting.
 
ir35 said:
Again, its my oppinion , I personally believe he's a terrible passer of the ball and a liabillity. He costs us as many points as he helps achieve. The fact hes not played outside the Premier league means nowt.
Click to expand...

Yes but your point was that Ba is better!

He's also better than Gardner
 
johnson said:
Answer me two things or you have failed miserably

Can you honestly say he hasn't been good in our last 5 away games?

You would honestly rather play Ba in a premier league relegation fight.

Answer me them, if you really think that you are absolutely mental
Click to expand...
When replies turn to abuse, you tend to be failing the argument, I'll leave it at that.
 
johnson said:
I don't disagree with all of that but he's still the least of our problems currently. Sell him in summer maybe but it's a ridiculous decision now. Be one injury away from Gardner starting.
Click to expand...
His error against Villa cost the goal and his sending off against Hull hurt us big time. He has some good games for sure but his errors have certainly hurt us. Mind if all that happens is replacing him with bloody Gardner then it would be daft to sell
 
ir35 said:
When replies turn to abuse, you tend to be failing the argument, I'll leave it at that.
Click to expand...

Abuse? I raised two valid points and you are refusing to answer them?

I wonder why this is?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top