11-a-side cricket at u11 is set up so that everyone is involved - batsmen have to retire at 20 (and the most able players get these quite sharpish) so teams generally use AT LEAST 8-9 batsmen in an innings. Similarly, a team must use at least 8 bowlers (4 can bowl 3 overs each, then a maximum of 2 per bowler). In reality, most clubs (including ours) have a wicket keeper and then the other 10 players bowl 2 overs each.
The huge difference is that pairs cricket is so detached from 11-a-side that it's practically a different game. The 11-a-side version gets kids used to bowling and fielding a proper cricket ball; and batsmen sharp learn how to value their wicket. In pairs if a batsmen has a swipe and is bowled, their team loses a few runs but they then just pick their stumps up and continue batting.
For those sides that have been playing proper u11 cricket for a number of years now; this is a massive step backwards.
Have a look at this game at U11 level - Washington v Ryhope.
You must be logged on to see external links
8 Washington lads batted, 4 of them faced less than 7 balls. 3 lads hogged the strike to try and make their retired target.
Then when Ryhope batted 4 of them got 5 balls or less and walked. 1 lad hogged the strike for 38 balls to make 9.
Pairs cricket means that each pair at that level will now face 30 balls between them ie far more cricket.
From the coast league link you put up
You must be logged on to see external links
Under 15's, I was also looking for a Houghton U13 and U11 team but they dont appear to have one.
Dawdon v Washington - non pairs cricket:
You must be logged on to see external links
5 Dawdon lads got ducks and walked.
7 of the Washington lads never got a bat.
Pointless.
Washington v Ryhope
6 of the Washington lads never batted
3 of the Ryhope lads never batted
If I was a parent of those lads I'd be very pissed off. They will now take far more interest when their lads bat for 5 overs - guaranteed. Far more batting time, far more chance of getting better and far more chance of them continuing to have an interest.
Washington v Murton:
6 of the Washington lads never got a bat
5 of the Murton lads never got a bat
Basically one whole team every game on average is not batting.