Colback or Henderson

[hank williams]

But colback to me is more of a destroyer when he in midfield. were as hendo is more creative player or supposed to be

 

[SAFCMarc]

Colback was always the better player, even when the pair were in the reserves.

 

[Dexter]

But colback to me is more of a destroyer when he in midfield. were as hendo is more creative player or supposed to be

One assist and one goal this season would suggest otherwise.

 

[mackemfrommilan]

But colback to me is more of a destroyer when he in midfield. were as hendo is A more creative player or supposed to be

They are two completely different types of footballers so it is hard to compare them.

I just think Colback is better at his game than Henderson is at his.

 

[HillView Aviator]

Colback is like a gigner Paul Scholes. Except Jack can tackle.

Whats Scholes like, a fuckin brunette?

 

[scotch]

altho he showed flashes of quality Henderson was never a stand out player over 90mins

Colback is quickly becoming one of our most important players

Was never too fussed on JC, but since his Brilliant performence at home against City he's been immense & is keeping Vaighan out of the team
Still think JH has greater potential but needed another season at Sunderlad to develop, if things don't improve he could be peddled onto a lower table prem team and ruin his career. Joey barton style

 

[mackemfrommilan]

One assist and one goal this season would suggest otherwise.

Colback has two goals. One against Smoggies and one against Everton(h).

 

[Travis]

He is a Ferguson type player, nothing special but puts a shift in and links up play extremely well. Supports the attack as much as the defence and us pretty dependable.

Still thought Henderson had the look of a player that could go on to big things though.

 

[L18SFC]

Whats Scholes like, a fuckin brunette?

 

[chuckyroll]

But colback to me is more of a destroyer when he in midfield. were as hendo is more creative player or supposed to be

 

[percy]

He's already better.

This.I've always said so and took a fair bit of stick for it.

 

[Hetzkes Ballet Teacher]

Shrewd judgement by Bruce to sell one for a fortune, and rely on the other coming on.

Fatty outwits the PF again.

 

[godsgifttoearth]

colback every time.

more versatile, more consistent.

 

[NickSAFC]

Tin hat on here but I reckon Colback will be a better player than Henderson. He offers so much more to the team than Henderson did.

His versatility is very useful as well, I thought he was shaky at wing back in the home tie against City but he was immense today.

Henderson always had the potential to give us something different going forward but his work rate and defending were embarrassing at times.

Colback, much more composed on the ball, can pass a ball better, great stamina and very versatile as well. We robbed Liverpool of £20m

 

[Billy Fish]

Colback, much more composed on the ball, can pass a ball better, great stamina and very versatile as well. We robbed Liverpool of £20m

No we robbed Liverpool of ten million

 

[NickSAFC]

No we robbed Liverpool of ten million

Yeah true, with the squad we got from his sale on wages and transfer fee's, great business by Bruce and Sunderland.

 

[rentaghost]

Colback is tremendous and NEVER plays badly. I honestly think Henderson has the ability to be a top player but i'm not sure he has the mental strength.

 

[Billy Fish]

Colback is tremendous and NEVER plays badly. I honestly think Henderson has the ability to be a top player but i'm not sure he has the mental strength.

And that's the biggest difference between the two. Jack seems unflappable with such a cool head no matter how big the occasion but Henderson disappears into his shell for the big games

 

[Macho]

He looks as though he's getting more comfortable every game, he does the donkey work. Been brilliant, he's such a tidy player, never panics and always finds a man. Turning into my favourite player.

I was not fan start of the season even though he was showing glimmers, but this half hes been f***ing fantasic.

If Henderson is worth 20 then JC is worth 30.

 

[Masterplan]

Where is Colback's best position?

First time I seen him play at left back was down Blackpool last season and he was very good and has probably played a handful more times in that position and has looked very good every time.

On the other hand over the last few month he has looked good in centre midfield now he has got more confidence in his ability.