• The forum upgrades are now largely complete.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

[the ashes] test 3. Manchester

Status
Not open for further replies.

Obviously hit it.

But you can't give it out.

I usually have very little sympathy for the Aussies but if that was given out then it would of been ridiculous.

If you are going to use hotspot, you have to trust it

chelt_mackem said:
It needs clarifying for caught behind decisions. LBW is clear enough now that there can't be any tactical reviews. A simple enough way of doing it would be to have a checklist like there is for LBW, deviation, noise and hotspot. For a decision given out on the field they all have to show no evidence of a nick (as they did for Khawaja) and for a decision given not out at least one of them has to show conclusive evidence of a nick.
Click to expand...

good post
 
johnson said:
Obviously hit it.

But you can't give it out.

I usually have very little sympathy for the Aussies but if that was given out then it would of been ridiculous.

If you are going to use hotspot, you have to trust it



good post
Click to expand...
There was nowt on snicko and nee deviation.
 
This is far more enjoyable than the lest Test imo. Cricket needs to be a contest, a duel, otherwise it's dull.
 
That had better not be a dodgy umpire evening things up. Both sides have lost reviews to bad umpiring and there's another poor decision.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top