• The forums will be unavailable for a few hours on Saturday 6th June, when they do return they will initially be in a degraded state with some features missing, but normal posting/reading will be possible. The main website will not be affected by these updates.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

Swann

Status
Not open for further replies.

essex boy said:
Broad 5th in the test rankings and shouldnt have been in the side for the start of this series. A sad indicment of test cricket
Click to expand...

Broad, Anderson and Swann are 3 parts of the best bowling attack in test cricket. I'm happy all of them are doing superbly particularly Broad who was the one that needed to step up to the plate and did. Whoever suggested he shouldn't have been picked were clearly wrong but who cares?
 
rentaghost said:
Broad, Anderson and Swann are 3 parts of the best bowling attack in test cricket. I'm happy all of them are doing superbly particularly Broad who was the one that needed to step up to the plate and did. Whoever suggested he shouldn't have been picked were clearly wrong but who cares?
Click to expand...

Only wrong with a great deal of hindsight though. Before the series started about 75% of cricket fans and pundits thought he should be dropped, and that's not because most of them didn't rate him, it was because he wasn't doing it and England had good bowlers such as Bresnan and Finn in reserve. Broad talent was never in question, his form was and I'm glad to say he's been outstanding in the series, the cricketer we know he should be.
 
The Breen Machine said:
Only wrong with a great deal of hindsight though. Before the series started about 75% of cricket fans and pundits thought he should be dropped, and that's not because most of them didn't rate him, it was because he wasn't doing it and England had good bowlers such as Bresnan and Finn in reserve. Broad talent was never in question, his form was and I'm glad to say he's been outstanding in the series, the cricketer we know he should be.
Click to expand...

He was really poor against Sri Lanka and a blind man could see it was as simple as pitching it up more consistently. The Sky Pundits had a poll of which quickie should be picked alongside anderson and Tremlett and only 1 out of 10 chose Broad and that was Nasser.
 
rentaghost said:
He was really poor against Sri Lanka and a blind man could see it was as simple as pitching it up more consistently. The Sky Pundits had a poll of which quickie should be picked alongside anderson and Tremlett and only 1 out of 10 chose Broad and that was Nasser.
Click to expand...

Tell it's own story, and you are right, everyone could see his lengths were causing him to look so innocuous. He's looked so much more dangerous in this series bowling a fuller length and I think he will go from strength to strength now.
 
rentaghost said:
He was really poor against Sri Lanka and a blind man could see it was as simple as pitching it up more consistently. The Sky Pundits had a poll of which quickie should be picked alongside anderson and Tremlett and only 1 out of 10 chose Broad and that was Nasser.
Click to expand...

and thats why the likes of Botham and Lloyd were not particularly great coaches and the likes of Atherton had a poor win ratio as skipper
 
essex boy said:
and thats why the likes of Botham and Lloyd were not particularly great coaches and the likes of Atherton had a poor win ratio as skipper
Click to expand...

Nothing to do with Ray Illingworth picking Joey Benjamin and Martin McCague to be his bowling attack eh?

Atherton was a decent captain who led from the front, but was let down by the poor structure of English cricket at the time.
 
EB having another attack on an England bowler, keep it coming this winter because they always seem to prove you wrong.
 
3 series on the trott, Swann has a series average of around 40.

having started off at 8 is now to 10 in the order anarl

first cracks are appearing
 
essex boy said:
maybe so but most test players hit a rocky spell as they get found out.

Strauss being the prime example, 2nd quickest to 2,000 test runs, dropped within the year
Click to expand...

Theres nothing to 'find out' about Swann. Hes an offie, he can give it plenty revs and has a slider. He can vary his pace and adapt to situations but theres very little batsmen learn about Swann over time. The '40' he has averaged over the last 3 series is actually top drawer given the conditions he has bowled in and the two opportunities he had to win a test he did. The '40' over the last 3 seasons is almost exactly the same average as harby has had in the last 5 years when half of his tst matches were in India.
 
rentaghost said:
Theres nothing to 'find out' about Swann. Hes an offie, he can give it plenty revs and has a slider. He can vary his pace and adapt to situations but theres very little batsmen learn about Swann over time. The '40' he has averaged over the last 3 series is actually top drawer given the conditions he has bowled in and the two opportunities he had to win a test he did. The '40' over the last 3 seasons is almost exactly the same average as harby has had in the last 5 years when half of his tst matches were in India.
Click to expand...

first cracks are starting to appear all I have said. Its easy to get to the top of the rankings, harder to stay there. Time will tell
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top