Rolling Stone magazine -100 greatest guitarists
- Thread starter ReaL Madras
- Start date
- Status
Martin F
Striker
But no Lita Ford?
A
Arthur Mullardo
Guest
see Jeff Beck is high up...confirms what local musicians say...loads of them go to see him when hes on..
J
Joe Fabulous
Guest
Yes, very highly thought of by his fellow musicians.
IknowWhatILike
Winger
Its the right people, but the order doesn't half seem skewed to me.
Missing Adrian Belew anarl imo, although he's not to everyone's taste
Missing Adrian Belew anarl imo, although he's not to everyone's taste
yorkyexile
Striker
Angus young 96? iommi and rhoads in the eighties?Les paul 46? someone got to be taking the piss
nee jo bonamasa, nee gary moore,no albert collins, no otis rush!! no prince(yes prince)The only good thing is theyre not still wanking themselves daft over dimebag darrel
nee jo bonamasa, nee gary moore,no albert collins, no otis rush!! no prince(yes prince)The only good thing is theyre not still wanking themselves daft over dimebag darrel
chriswallace85
Striker
Hmm, looked at the top ten and though 'meh'. Looks like a journo trying to be clever. Can't see why Robert Johnson's in the top 10, above the likes of Jimmy Page. Well, I know why he is, 'cos the journo's trying to be clever and make some form of statement regarding what came first. He's got it wrong though. Robert Johnson's egg may have come first, but Page's chicken was a lot bigger and a lot tastier. 
b1gals
Striker
And the irony is Bill Bailey is telling 500 people that what U2 do in front of 60000+ is shite
:roll:
alicante mackem
Striker
Hmm, looked at the top ten and though 'meh'. Looks like a journo trying to be clever. Can't see why Robert Johnson's in the top 10, above the likes of Jimmy Page. Well, I know why he is, 'cos the journo's trying to be clever and make some form of statement regarding what came first. He's got it wrong though. Robert Johnson's egg may have come first, but Page's chicken was a lot bigger and a lot tastier.
For somebody with a Dylan avatar I´m surprised you´ve made this terrible error of judgement. Dylan would certainly tell you, you are wrong.
Captain Slackbladder
Winger
Tis a disgrace...where the fucks Francis Rossi.
supernaut1968
Striker
He is. Great player as well!
alicante mackem
Striker
Is there any way of seeing a list of the top 100, I don´t want to spend half an hour clicking on 1 to 100. What number is Neil Young? certainly not the most technically gifted rock guitarist the world has heard, but he´s the one I most like listening too.
Oh and the greatest guitatist is Paco Lucia.
Oh and the greatest guitatist is Paco Lucia.
J
Joe Fabulous
Guest
Neil in at around 60 something. Probably a fair assessment . As you say, he's not the most technical player.
Agreed. Technically superb player.
chriswallace85
Striker
Then I'd argue the toss with him. Tell me why he's not above Clapton, King and Allman then??? It just doesn't make sense.
alicante mackem
Striker
He was 17, probably about right.
chriswallace85
Striker
I could understand if it was "100 most influential guitarists of all time", but it's not.
alicante mackem
Striker
Tell me why he's not above Clapton, King and Allman then??? It just doesn't make sense.
I don´t know he should be. Peter Green was in somewhere around 50 as was Muddy Waters :roll:
J
Joe Fabulous
Guest
Last edited by a moderator:
- Status
