• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Redditors gave Wall Street traders an absolute pasting

the circuit breakers have been in place for years. it's nothing new.
We agree on these points in principle at least.

Personally it looks to me like an extremely volatile market... triggered by short selling.

No need to answer but I wonder if you would you have been quite as fervent in your support for retail investors if (hypothetically) the SP of another company had gone from 400 dollars to 2 dollars as a result of shorting? This Reddit shit is shock of the new and people at institutions (I'm assuming you work for one? sorry if not) are very wary and spooked by it.

Maybe memestocks are a new investment trend, a loophole looked at unfavourably and extremely high risk/reward. Either way, both seem pretty fucked to me - and can't help but think they'll cause huge losses either side of the fence this time with stocks like AMC/GME etc.
the shorts have been in place for months. it's the buying hype that has increased the beta.
 
Last edited:

We agree on these points in principle at least.

Personally it looks to me like an extremely volatile market... triggered by short selling.

No need to answer but I wonder if you would you have been quite as fervent in your support for retail investors if (hypothetically) the SP of another company had gone from 400 dollars to 2 dollars as a result of shorting? This Reddit shit is shock of the new and people at institutions (I'm assuming you work for one? sorry if not) are very wary and spooked by it.

Maybe memestocks are a new investment trend, a loophole looked at unfavourably and extremely high risk/reward. Either way, both seem pretty fucked to me - and can't help but think they'll cause huge losses either side of the fence this time with stocks like AMC/GME etc.
It hasn't been triggered by shorts and let's be honest when this firm which is like a budget blockbuster cant deliver the results the share price predicts, guess who is going to be caught with no pants as the tide goes out.
 
A disorderly market is where there is excessive volatility. There's nothing wrong with shares going from 2 dollars to 400 dollars. As long as its orderly and buyers and sellers can participate.
But who’s stopping the buyers and sellers participating right now? Not the redditors?

Does the SEC define “orderly”?
 
“Disorderly market conditions “ seems to be a very conveniently vague phrase that can be defined whenever the regulators fancy?

Exactly.
Not at all. Eurex is the only exchange that has vague disorderly market parameters. They call it a volatility interruption. The cme and nyse have very strict conditions which would trigger a circuit breaker (preventing disorderly markets)
But who’s stopping the buyers and sellers participating right now? Not the redditors?

Does the SEC define “orderly”?
Not sure if there is a strict definition tbh
 
Last edited:
the circuit breakers have been in place for years. it's nothing new.

the shorts have been in place for months.

Again... not trying to be a c u next tuesday here.

So what? :lol: :lol:

No short in the first place = no Reddit short squeeze now

You know that phrase you see pop up on every single ad for investment brokerages "your capital is at risk, you may not get back what you put in"

I reckon the funds who make their corn going short on these securities know that better than most and shouldn't need a pickmeup from any of us.
 
Not at all. Eurex is the only exchange that has vague disorderly market parameters. They call it a volatility interruption. The cme and nyse have very strict conditions which would trigger a circuit breaker (preventing disorderly markets)

Not sure if there is a strict definition tbh
So they get to decide what constitutes orderly then. That’s not very good regulation, if you ask me.
 
Again... not trying to be a c u next tuesday here.

So what? :lol: :lol:

No short in the first place = no Reddit short squeeze now

You know that phrase you see pop up on every single ad for investment brokerages "your capital is at risk, you may not get back what you put in"

I reckon the funds who make their corn going short on these securities know that better than most and shouldn't need a pickmeup from any of us.
Do you think I'm defending the hedge funds in question here? I'm absolutely not.
So they get to decide what constitutes orderly then. That’s not very good regulation, if you ask me.
If you don't want the regulator or exchange (de facto regulator) to decide. Who do you want to decide?
Brutal but to be expected. These firms have no prospects reflecting the recent SP.

@monkeytassle and @nyron4england running down the beach collecting all the swimsuits as we speak ;);)
This is my point. Guess who is long at 20 bucks...
 
Last edited:
So they get to decide what constitutes orderly then. That’s not very good regulation, if you ask me.

In my experience it's very, very complicated.. :cool:

There are so many interconnected systems all with checks and balances to try and maintain orderly liquidity across the markets. That includes options, multiple other exchanges and all sorts of other instruments..

Add in the behind the scenes broker dealer systems that try and place transactions via market makers etc and these situations happen.

E.g. Citadel is the largest MM for Nyse retail investors, and their systems probably suspend/shut down if they cannot provide adequate liquidity or handle spikes in trading volumes at times of very high volatility.
 
In my experience it's very, very complicated.. :cool:

There are so many interconnected systems all with checks and balances to try and maintain orderly liquidity across the markets. That includes options, multiple other exchanges and all sorts of other instruments..

Add in the behind the scenes broker dealer systems that try and place transactions via market makers etc and these situations happen.

E.g. Citadel is the largest MM for Nyse retail investors, and their systems probably suspend/shut down if they cannot provide adequate liquidity or handle spikes in trading volumes at times of very high volatility.
It's not probably. They do.
 
GameStop down 43% (58% from today's peak)

Harsh lesson incoming for anyone piling into Robinhood, Trading212 etc. for the first time today at $469

The Reddit ringleaders egging folk on to keep on buying and the trading platforms who have blocked buying are just as bad as the shorts.

What a shitshow.
 
Back
Top