Amaw
Full Back
Here's the thing. The best either of us could hope for at present is mid-table mediocrity (a world away for us at present I know). Rafa performed perfectly well in his remit to achieve that - I for one think he is a good manager. Mike Ashley to my mind has actually given him the platform with which to accomplish this also. So what is the point? To me, if you can remain reasonably comfortable in the top division, sign the odd decent player, put a few results together, you might actually come within grasp of achieving something in the cups. We went close in 2014. Ok it was only the League Cup and not the FA Cup, but if we had come away with that trophy I honestly think I could have died a happy Sunderland supporter. So my question to you is, after a couple of reasonably comfortable finishes in the Premier League, where was Rafa's ambition in those cup competitions?
I'm not entirely sure what more Newcastle fans expect to achieve in the current climate, but I don't think a cup run would have been too far fetched an idea. And I'm sorry like, but Mike Ashley is not the one to blame for you not having one.
I agree with you on managers not prioritising the cups, something I can never grasp. No it is not Ashleys fault entirely for this. However Rafa is not the first and wont be the last manager to play the kids in these cups, if you are the manager of Chelsea or Man U your squad is usually a little thicker with better players on the peripherals, clubs like Newcastle have a starting 11 and maybe a couple of good players sitting on the bench, but our squad depth is shyte (please no one say "its Shite") as is most of us lower Premier league clubs. So when you are in a relegation battle, as a Manager do you want to risk your stars getting over tiered (something I also disagree with) or injured, playing Bury on a cold December in a early round league cup game? As a fan I do, but Managers don't.
So with a little investment if we were not annual relegation fodder, our Manager might just risk a cup game. So that is where I put some blame onto Ashley, Ultimately though it's the Manager who picks the team.