List A cricket - 60th anniversary

B

bumble2

Full Back
How it all began. And we’re still trying to solve the same sort of problems!

wisdenblog.wordpress.com

The one-day cup final turns 60

Kit Harris celebrates the one-day final’s diamond jubilee A jubilee is usually worth celebrating, and September 7, 2023 marks a particularly auspicious anniversary for modern cricket; it was on thi…
wisdenblog.wordpress.com wisdenblog.wordpress.com
 


bumble2 said:
How it all began. And we’re still trying to solve the same sort of problems!

wisdenblog.wordpress.com

The one-day cup final turns 60

Kit Harris celebrates the one-day final’s diamond jubilee A jubilee is usually worth celebrating, and September 7, 2023 marks a particularly auspicious anniversary for modern cricket; it was on thi…
wisdenblog.wordpress.com wisdenblog.wordpress.com
Click to expand...

World Champions and still the ECB have downgraded it…
 
Voice of fair play said:
There is always some twisting mate it’s in their nature.

In fact it’s a running theme on this board
Click to expand...
In it's original form it was little different to established cricket. White clothing,red ball and no fielding restrictions. Never heard or read of any disapproval. Different forms of the game have evolved to appeal to varying tastes However, cricket fans are fully entitled to their preferred form of cricket surely. Why label then "twisting?"
 
Parkside said:
In its original form it was little different to established cricket. White clothing,red ball and no fielding restrictions. Never heard or read of any disapproval. Different forms of the game have evolved to appeal to varying tastes However, cricket fans are fully entitled to their preferred form of cricket surely. Why label then "twisting?"
Click to expand...
Of course people have their preferred form that’s perfectly natural

However what I have seen over many years on this board, that is more what I was alluding too, is a lot lot more negative comments than positive ones over various subjects involving cricket, even more soo recently

I suppose tbf having a forum to express views encourages that to a point, so I maybe I am been a little bit unfair.

But what I see after watching cricket for 40 years in this country is the current game in all formats is more entertaining than ever before!! , by quite a long way, and the England team taking into account all formats is also more successful than ever before!!

Taking into account both them two elements you would think would provide positive after positive comments about cricket in England at the moment.

But I simply don’t see a lot of positive comments about that on here.

But I do see a lot of twisting outweighing positive comments
 
Last edited:
Voice of fair play said:
Of course people have their preferred form that’s perfectly natural

However what I have seen over many years on this board, that is more what I was alluding too, is a lot lot more negative comments than positive ones over various subjects involving cricket, even more soo recently

I suppose tbf having a forum to express views encourages that to a point, so I maybe I am been a little bit unfair.

But what I see after watching cricket for 40 years in this country is the current game in all formats is more entertaining than ever before!! , by quite a long way, and the England team taking into account all formats is also more successful than ever before!!

Taking into account both them two elements you would think would provide positive after positive comments about cricket in England at the moment.

But I simply don’t see a lot of positive comments about that on here.

But I do see a lot of twisting outweighing positive comments
Click to expand...
It would be a rather boring and pointless forum if everyone agreed on every topic. The objection I was making is that people offering a conflicting view aren't " twisting".
I don't have a problem with your view that everything in cricket is better than ever in your lifetime( have you watched England's last 3 white ball games.🤔?) but I ' d disagree. Conflicting views should be accepted and not implied as being negative,moaning or twisting.
 
Parkside said:
It would be a rather boring and pointless forum if everyone agreed on every topic. The objection I was making is that people offering a conflicting view aren't " twisting".
I don't have a problem with your view that everything in cricket is better than ever in your lifetime( have you watched England's last 3 white ball games.🤔?) but I ' d disagree. Conflicting views should be accepted and not implied as being negative,moaning or twisting.
Click to expand...
Well yes totally agree it’s what makes this board interesting contrasting views and totally respect yours and totally see your above point.

And always enjoy the debate with yourself


Was just making two points mainly, that link.

One been a general point that there is a more negative than positive comments about English cricket on this board from what I have read and two I find that surprising considering the current success taking into all formats and the superb entertainment on show, especially the total revolution and exciting brand of test cricket we now playing.
 
Last edited:
Voice of fair play said:
Well yes totally agree it’s what makes this board interesting contrasting views and totally respect yours and totally see your above point.

And always enjoy the debate with yourself


Was just making two points mainly, that link.

One been a general point that there is a more negative than positive comments about English cricket on this board from what I have read and two I find that surprising considering the current success taking into all formats and the superb entertainment on show, especially the total revolution and exciting brand of test cricket we now playing.
Click to expand...
I suppose whether a comment is negative or positive is purely subjective. There were many advocating Anderson should have been dropped to be replaced by Tongue. Is that a criticism of Anderson or a positive comment to improve the team overall ?
Again,It's simply a personal opinion.
 
brandon said:
Has a moan about ‘twisting’ by doing exactly the same themselves :lol:
Click to expand...
Aye you right I do, I twist about the twisters:D
Parkside said:
I suppose whether a comment is negative or positive is purely subjective. There were many advocating Anderson should have been dropped to be replaced by Tongue. Is that a criticism of Anderson or a positive comment to improve the team overall ?
Again,It's simply a personal opinion.
Click to expand...
I think that’s a positive comment to improve the team.

But I am more talking about general negative comments outweighing positive comments
 
Last edited:
brandon said:
Makes you no better than them then, doesn’t it…
Click to expand...
Like I said to you a thousand times mate it’s not about winning or been better it’s just expressing opinions.


The England test team is the most entertaining it’s ever been by a country mile, we world champions in other two formats.

And we seem to have all of sudden depth as well with young players coming through.

I am generally a positive person therefore I genuinely struggle why the above is not extremely positive for English cricket and am simply expressing that view, that I am surprised why there is not more positive comments in general for English cricket
 
Last edited:
I swear the most argumentative people on the entire board are all on the cricket forum.

I only have a handful of people on ignore but the entire sub forum is just a load of one sided arguments between all the regulars and a few people i can't see :lol:
 
I thought the Wisden article was really interesting. Shame it just provoked the same old squabbles. Did anyone actually read it?
 

Back
Top