Daniels
Striker
Leeds are flogging the message board off to York. It’s a fire sale over there.
-
The forums will be unavailable for a few hours on Saturday 6th June, when they do return they will initially be in a degraded state with some features missing, but normal posting/reading will be possible. The main website will not be affected by these updates.
New user registrations are currently disabled.
Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.
Jack Clarke
- Thread starter skunk hater
- Start date
Hulkster
Striker
Tonight I am mostly asking Grok about football. I asked it for a fair assessment of Clarke's transfer value:
Given the information available up to August 20, 2024, here's a fair assessment of Jack Clarke's transfer value:
Market Value: Clarke's market value has been cited around €15 million, which translates to roughly £13 million based on current exchange rates. However, transfer fees often exceed market values due to various factors.
Recent Transfers: Looking at similar profiles:
Wilfried Gnonto from FC Zurich to Leeds United was around £21 million, but he's younger and had a different profile (more of a forward).
Noni Madueke moved to Chelsea for £29 million, but he was coming from PSV Eindhoven, which might have influenced the price due to the Dutch league's reputation for producing top talents.
Performance Metrics: Clarke's performance in the Championship has been stellar, with high rankings in dribbling, chance creation, and goal contributions. His ability to influence games positively suggests his value could be on the higher end for Championship players.
Contract Status: Clarke has two years left on his contract with Sunderland, which gives Sunderland some leverage but also means they might need to sell if a substantial offer comes in to avoid losing him for free or for a reduced fee later.
Interest from Higher Leagues: Interest from Premier League clubs like Southampton, West Ham, and potentially others indicates his readiness for the top flight, which could inflate his value due to the demand.
Sunderland's Valuation: Sunderland reportedly values Clarke at £25 million, which seems ambitious but not entirely out of line considering:
English Talent: There's a premium on English players, especially those showing promise in the Championship with an eye on the Premier League.
Sell-On Clause: Tottenham's 25% sell-on clause might push the price higher since any buying club would need to cover this, effectively increasing the cost.
Public Sentiment and X Posts: There's a sentiment among fans and analysts that Clarke's value could be in the £20-30 million range, especially when comparing him to other recent transfers and considering his age, nationality, and performance.
Fair Assessment:
Lower Bound: Given his market value and the typical premium for English talents, a lower bound might be around £15-18 million, considering his contract situation and the need for Sunderland to reinvest in their squad.
Upper Bound: With the interest from Premier League clubs, his performances, and the market's trend of overpaying for potential, an upper bound could be justified at £25-30 million, especially if a bidding war ensues or if a club is particularly desperate for a player of Clarke's profile.
Realistic Transfer Fee: Given all factors, a realistic transfer fee might be in the £20-25 million range. This accounts for:
His market value.
The potential for growth and the premium for English players.
The interest from higher leagues indicating his readiness for a step up.
Sunderland's need to ensure they get a good return but also the reality of transfer negotiations where clubs often start with higher valuations.
This assessment considers both the financial aspects of transfers and Clarke's footballing attributes, suggesting that while £25 million might be Sunderland's starting point, a deal could realistically be struck within the £20-25 million range, considering all market dynamics.
Given the information available up to August 20, 2024, here's a fair assessment of Jack Clarke's transfer value:
Market Value: Clarke's market value has been cited around €15 million, which translates to roughly £13 million based on current exchange rates. However, transfer fees often exceed market values due to various factors.
Recent Transfers: Looking at similar profiles:
Wilfried Gnonto from FC Zurich to Leeds United was around £21 million, but he's younger and had a different profile (more of a forward).
Noni Madueke moved to Chelsea for £29 million, but he was coming from PSV Eindhoven, which might have influenced the price due to the Dutch league's reputation for producing top talents.
Performance Metrics: Clarke's performance in the Championship has been stellar, with high rankings in dribbling, chance creation, and goal contributions. His ability to influence games positively suggests his value could be on the higher end for Championship players.
Contract Status: Clarke has two years left on his contract with Sunderland, which gives Sunderland some leverage but also means they might need to sell if a substantial offer comes in to avoid losing him for free or for a reduced fee later.
Interest from Higher Leagues: Interest from Premier League clubs like Southampton, West Ham, and potentially others indicates his readiness for the top flight, which could inflate his value due to the demand.
Sunderland's Valuation: Sunderland reportedly values Clarke at £25 million, which seems ambitious but not entirely out of line considering:
English Talent: There's a premium on English players, especially those showing promise in the Championship with an eye on the Premier League.
Sell-On Clause: Tottenham's 25% sell-on clause might push the price higher since any buying club would need to cover this, effectively increasing the cost.
Public Sentiment and X Posts: There's a sentiment among fans and analysts that Clarke's value could be in the £20-30 million range, especially when comparing him to other recent transfers and considering his age, nationality, and performance.
Fair Assessment:
Lower Bound: Given his market value and the typical premium for English talents, a lower bound might be around £15-18 million, considering his contract situation and the need for Sunderland to reinvest in their squad.
Upper Bound: With the interest from Premier League clubs, his performances, and the market's trend of overpaying for potential, an upper bound could be justified at £25-30 million, especially if a bidding war ensues or if a club is particularly desperate for a player of Clarke's profile.
Realistic Transfer Fee: Given all factors, a realistic transfer fee might be in the £20-25 million range. This accounts for:
His market value.
The potential for growth and the premium for English players.
The interest from higher leagues indicating his readiness for a step up.
Sunderland's need to ensure they get a good return but also the reality of transfer negotiations where clubs often start with higher valuations.
This assessment considers both the financial aspects of transfers and Clarke's footballing attributes, suggesting that while £25 million might be Sunderland's starting point, a deal could realistically be struck within the £20-25 million range, considering all market dynamics.
Nelson!
Striker
Please stop leveling rain forests for this man.
Idlewild Mackem
Striker
Remarkably, less wankers
Lucky1985
Winger
Christ that grok is a wordy little fucker isn’t it, we asked for a number his life’s story!
Shieldsman
Striker
We’ll be improving the award plenty if upping the wage structure results in retaining JC, promotion and a load of money to spend on PL standard players.
There is the issue he’s played pretty much his whole career on the right wing.
Last edited:
I see £15m-£20m quoted as Jack Clarke's transfer value.
Yet Leeds get £40m for Georginho Rutter, whose goal return is dogshit by comparison.
Why is Clarke priced so low ?
Yet Leeds get £40m for Georginho Rutter, whose goal return is dogshit by comparison.
Why is Clarke priced so low ?
I watched Hoffenheim regularly and he was only a sub for them. Couldn’t believe they bought him for such a high fee.
safcyank
Central Defender
So the last few times I've seen Rutter play, he has played more as a ten than a striker. 16 assists last year. 40m is high, but I feel like he's improved a lot even if his goal tally doesn't reflect it. And he's only 22.
Mitoma, Pedro, Ferguson, and Rutter. Not a bad group there
Whitburnmakem
Striker
was got bags of skill and ability
Nelson!
Striker
Been wondering the same. He’s “only 22”…..Clarke is 23.
Not as good a finisher, doesn’t work as hard, doesn’t get as many assists. Is it just because he’s Brazilian?
GiantHogweed
Striker
National embarrassment on the handling of the last derby followed by firing our last manager after 63 days on the job then setting a record for the longest timeframe without a manager after multiple candidates said thanks but no thanks.
My guess is buying clubs are purposely low balling offers to us because they think we're run poorly and may bite ... and the player valuations also reflect that.
I could be wrong about that - just an opinion.
Last edited:
It is odd
Could be in a position where Leeds buy Clarke to replace Rutter, pocket £20m and end up with a better player
Last edited:
Daniels
Striker
It’s the weird Premier League tax. As soon as a player or manager gets into the Premier League now it only takes a handful of good games to multiply value. I would love us to go up and see how much Bellingham, Clarke, Hume, Cirkin and Rigg suddenly become.
hertsmackem
Striker
He doesn’t need to , Stevie Wonder can see how effective he is.£40 mil or he stays
taipeisafc
Striker
I am sure I read it was a release clause in his contract that Brighton invoked just before it expired. Seems over the top for me too.
I agree, but the most likely way that will happen is with Clarke on his current contract.
safcyank
Central Defender
I think he's got a higher ceiling than Jack. I would rather have Jack in our squad with our personnel than Rutter, but I understand why his valuation is higher. He isn't really a striker either. Can be a second striker but is more of a 10 now. He had 16 assists last season in a Leeds team that didn't need his goals, playing deeper behind Piroe or Bamford. Also he's French. Could be wrong, but I bet Brighton more than get their money back out of him in a few years. When he does move, maybe I'll remember to come back and check this. Probably not.
