-
The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on. Normal posting/reading should now be possible.
Please read this thread for more details.
New user registrations are currently disabled.
Disallowed goal...
- Thread starter McGregor
- Start date
FalkirkMackem
Striker
indeed
Then Alderete didn’t get a penalty for the same thing happening to him - they make it up as they go along man.
vote quimby
Striker
The slight touch didn't effect the way the GK was already pushing off his feet to save the ball. Poor decision for me. Just because it's contact doesn't mean it's causing an obstruction.
SunderLad92
Midfield
Apparently if you make contact after your challenge even if it's slight from your follow through it's a foul.
Forest defender makes a challenge and stamps on Alderetes foot with the follow through but that's not a penalty.
Forest defender makes a challenge and stamps on Alderetes foot with the follow through but that's not a penalty.
Tom SAFC
Winger
Would have made very little difference of course, but makes a mockery of clear and obvious. They spent 3-4 minutes and even when the ref went over to the monitor he took some convincing, but bottled going against the voice in his ear.
VAR should not be searching for opportunities to disallow goals, not one Forrest player including the keeper appealed for it. Ref was shite all night, for both teams as well.
VAR should not be searching for opportunities to disallow goals, not one Forrest player including the keeper appealed for it. Ref was shite all night, for both teams as well.
Coeus
Striker
They really do. Its all over the bloody shop.
Tom SAFC
Winger
Complete lack of consistency. FWIW the Alderete one I think is 50-50, but arguably reckless to stamp on him like that regardless of having won the ball.
FlashGordon
Midfield
Would have been a different game If that went in. Ref cost us.
SunderLad92
Midfield
Ah don't get me wrong I'm clutching at straws with the Alderete one but if that's the route they want to go down for the disallowed goal surely see out the 90 minutes with them views
BoshItLikeBardo
Midfield
It was pathetic. I’m sure if you watched their goals back closely enough you’d find one of their players touching one of our players.
I was more than happy for Xhaka to take a booking for giving the ref a bollocking.
I was more than happy for Xhaka to take a booking for giving the ref a bollocking.
ChrisSandDancerFTM
New Member
Who gives a fuck even if it was given it would’ve been 5-1, the least of our worries
Tom SAFC
Winger
Aye the consistency point still stands as Mukiele won the ball then skimmed their keepers leg - I must have missed when football became a non contact sportAh don't get me wrong I'm clutching at straws with the Alderete one but if that's the route they want to go down for the disallowed goal surely see out the 90 minutes with them views
Wasn't a foul like, keeper was already on the way up so had no pressure through the leg that was brushed by NM. Didn't impact his movement at all.
Hate VAR. I know it has been good to us, but I'd gladly see it entirely binned off forever.
Hate VAR. I know it has been good to us, but I'd gladly see it entirely binned off forever.
19FTM73
Winger
Mentioned before, but how that was diff to the non foul on alderete in the box i dont know
Even with technology helping them, the officials are shit. Or biased. Or both.
