• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Alex Neil - New head coach confirmed

Status
Not open for further replies.

I wonder if it ever crossed anyone's mind to go and ask Wayne Rooney if he would be interested. The work he is doing at Derby is bordering on a miracle and if he succeeds in keeping them up he should be a candidate for Manager of the Year. I think Neil if appointed sounds and feels about right, hope he if gets the job he brings a bit of good fortune with him because there's none available at our club and he's going to need it.
No chance. Everton approached him, and he rejected the interview invitation.
He’s made it extremely clear all season that he wants to see it out with Derby, and try to keep them up.
 
Sounds as positive as we're likely to get. Mind the bit about struggling to break down teams that have a deep defensive line is a major worry given that's how about 80% of the teams in this division play against us
Tbf I didn’t want Keane back. I would have probably preferred a more progressive appointment, but in terms of a realistic appointment with experience of the level above and someone who’s won promotion via a play off, he’s the best we’ll get.
 
He’s got a record of instant results and promotions. Took Hamilton up in his first season in charge and took over Norwich in the January with them outside the play-offs and took them up as well. Won 17 of his first 25 games there to win promotion.
We’d all take that now, although if he can get us up with the state of the current team it will be some achievement.
 
I wonder if it ever crossed anyone's mind to go and ask Wayne Rooney if he would be interested. The work he is doing at Derby is bordering on a miracle and if he succeeds in keeping them up he should be a candidate for Manager of the Year. I think Neil if appointed sounds and feels about right, hope he if gets the job he brings a bit of good fortune with him because there's none available at our club and he's going to need it.
Because Derby are a more stable alternative than us? ;)
 
They would have known his demands from the start though. If they were not acceptable then you move on. It would appear we’ve tried to negotiate for well over a week, in the hope things change.
I dont believe it was ever going to be Keane. They've got into a position and tried to calm it and probably gave him a poor offer ao he knocks it back.
 
Fair point mate but sometimes you just have to ask the question.
Wouldn’t have been against it myself! We need someone who will demand respect, and also ideally has played/managed at a high level and got results.

Keane, Rooney, etc fit that bill for me. Anyway, we’ll have to do with someone who will accept what Speakman has to say.
 
Tbf I didn’t want Keane back. I would have probably preferred a more progressive appointment, but in terms of a realistic appointment with experience of the level above and someone who’s won promotion via a play off, he’s the best we’ll get.
My concern about the play off thing is that I always see them as a bit of a gamble. One bad performance, one daft red card or poor refereeing decision can decide the games, so I'm not sure having been lucky enough to win one (or two in his case) really suggests he's a good shout for any upcoming ones. Maybe not realistic with the teams he's had but I'd feel a lot more comfortable with a manager who has got a team winning consistently enough to get top two. Still, fans at former clubs seem to think he's decent so I guess we'd need to give it a go and hope it works. Enthusiasm will be at an all time low mind, it's not fair on him but he'll have a job just to get a fair section of the fans interested again. Got no faith in the direction this clubs going. If he improves us and we're in the play offs I'll no doubt allow optimism to get the better of me mind
 
Sounds as positive as we're likely to get. Mind the bit about struggling to break down teams that have a deep defensive line is a major worry given that's how about 80% of the teams in this division play against us
I wouldn’t worry about too much. With us it was mainly because we didn’t have the quality of players. We lacked creativity badly. Your squad is definitely good enough.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top