Edinburgh Black Cat
Striker
I quite like Alex Scott. Crouchy would be good as well.
A Question of Sport
- Thread starter The Breen Machine
- Start date
Sidewinder2
Striker
I don't think anyone would mind if it was based on presenting skills but it's not
She's an awful pundit and has no experience. Someone like Eilidh Barbour however is a decent presenter on the lasses footy and has done final score etc. Unfortunately she ain't black
Same as Clem being shafted off the EFL on final score for Kelly Sommers who messes up the technology and reports etc at least once a week
Wait till the netballs on, I'll be lobbying for Roy Keane to present it
She's an awful pundit and has no experience. Someone like Eilidh Barbour however is a decent presenter on the lasses footy and has done final score etc. Unfortunately she ain't black
Same as Clem being shafted off the EFL on final score for Kelly Sommers who messes up the technology and reports etc at least once a week
Wait till the netballs on, I'll be lobbying for Roy Keane to present it
Last edited:
naughtynose
Striker
How on earth do they still get away with it. Its car crash TV
mysticmackem
Striker
Didn't Reidy spill the beans, about all the jokes, and patter being scripted and rehearsed ?
I love the outrage from the usual few.
“A woman? She hasn’t played at the top level!!!”
replaces another woman
“not that type of woman!!!!”
“A woman? She hasn’t played at the top level!!!”
replaces another woman
“not that type of woman!!!!”
Mackem00
Striker
Absolutely cringey telly in its current form. So bad it is almost worth watching. The sport version of Top Gear.
Bizarre that people have a problem with her like.
Last edited:
Sidewinder2
Striker
I don't have a problem with her but as I said earlier what is wrong with someone like Eilidh Barbour? Loads of presenting experience, football focus, golf, loads of other sports. She must be gutted she ain't black.
Sexual and race equality is a good thing without a shadow of a doubt, going so far the other way I would say does more damage than good
Last edited:
Mackem00
Striker
Did she want the job like?
Charmless Man
Striker
This. Its an awful programme.
Sidewinder2
Striker
We'll never know
Was there a selection process or was it just offered to Scott?
Again we don't know
Last edited:
Charmless Man
Striker
Excellent if true.
Attractive, good presenter and will annoy people I want to be annoyed.
Still won't watch as its a shit format
Mackem00
Striker
So what's your point? She might have wanted the job she might not have even applied for or wanted? Should they make her do it?
Doesn't sound like she's struggling with BBC box ticking if she is doing aswell as it sounds.
Sidewinder2
Striker
My point is how do you know she didn't?
Martin F
Striker
Agreed, it epitomises the dumbing down of TV.
Charmless Man
Striker
How do you know any number of people didn't?
Mackem00
Striker
I don't. That's why I didn't say she should have been given the job. Why would she be gutted she isn't black?
Sidewinder2
Striker
We don't that's my point.
Charmless Man
Striker
Grrrr, I bet Sol Cambell is going to be one of the captains. And Dianne Abbott.
Do TV producers recruit in the same way other hiring managers do?
Do TV producers recruit in the same way other hiring managers do?
Sidewinder2
Striker
I didn't say she should've been given the job. What I am saying is if it was an interview process etc how would she lose out
If it wasn't an interview process then that would emphasise the point.
Mackem00
Striker
So what is your point here?
