• The forum upgrades are now largely complete.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

4th Ashes Test - Durham

Status
Not open for further replies.

Lets just get back to leaving it to the on field umpires. This is spoiling the game.
 
Steak Pie said:
What a massive load of shite.

The Ump gave him out caught, so he can't possibly have given him out LBW.
Click to expand...

its becoming, if not already, a shambles. These umpires are poor, the DRS is flawed, teams use it tactically rather than to overturn shockers. Im starting to favour going back to how it was where you win some you lose some with umpires decisions
 
Steak Pie said:
What a massive load of shite.

The Ump gave him out caught, so he can't possibly have given him out LBW.
Click to expand...

Apparently you can.

Watched a SA v Pak ODI when younis Khan was given out caught behind when the saffers appealed a LBW via DRS. The Umps had said not out to a lbw appeal but the saffers appealed, Khan nicked it on his pads thus nullifing the lbw but then was given caught behind.
 
Did you give him out LBW?
No, because he hit it.
He didn't hit it.
Oh, right.
So he's out LBW then?
Erm, no.
But it was hitting the stumps.
So?
He's out then?
No.

It's bollocks man. :lol:
 
ProfessionalMackem said:
Apparently you can.

Watched a SA v Pak ODI when younis Khan was given out caught behind when the saffers appealed a LBW via DRS. The Umps had said not out to a lbw appeal but the saffers appealed, Khan nicked it on his pads thus nullifing the lbw but then was given caught behind.
Click to expand...

Well as we've just seen, should have been not out.
 
I don't get how when looking at the replay of it, it shows it's an LBW yet it's still not given out, it's baffling!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top