• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

4th Ashes Test - Durham

Status
Not open for further replies.

rentaghost said:
How on earth can Atherton blame an umpire for giving a player out LBW who was proven to be out LBW albeit maginally?
Click to expand...

He didn't blame the umpire, he said haddin can feel a bit aggrieved, which bearing in mind the margins he can. Don't think many umpires would have given it to be honest.
 
smoker said:
Me. They looked safe as houses at 4 o'clock. Fess up, you thought we'd blown it and all.

;)
Click to expand...

I always felt it would come down to Clarke. They have forgotten how to win and and to me this chase was all about whether Clarke could see his team home.
 
Behind Enemy Lines said:
Because it was just a guess, knowing that DRS would cover him either way. Watson is right, DRS has taken the benefit of the doubt from the batsman.
Click to expand...

Most LBW decision's are educated guesses. it's a tough one, as technically he was out. However, It would have hit the stumps.
 
Behind Enemy Lines said:
Because it was just a guess, knowing that DRS would cover him either way. Watson is right, DRS has taken the benefit of the doubt from the batsman.
Click to expand...

Most LBW's are best guesses. The ball hit him in line was going on to hit the stumps - if he had given not out he would have been rightly criticised. You can't slag a bloke off for making a correct decision FFS.
 
1 more tonight would do. Not sure i'd take the extra 30min, give Broad a chance to have another blast in the morning.
 
Ricci's Special Kebabs said:
How exactly was it a guess, if he thinks its out his finger should go up.
Click to expand...

I don't think umpires should be giving batsmen out when the decision is a marginal as that, it just smacks of guessing/arse covering.

"If I'm wrong, it'll be overturned anyway so no harm done. Oh, it clipped the stumps by a milimetre, decision stands, unlucky batsman."

The umpiring this series has been crap in general.
 
Behind Enemy Lines said:
I don't think umpires should be giving batsmen out when the decision is a marginal as that, it just smacks of guessing/arse covering.

"If I'm wrong, it'll be overturned anyway so no harm done. Oh, it clipped the stumps by a milimetre, decision stands, unlucky batsman."

The umpiring this series has been crap in general.
Click to expand...
yep. Far too many times they've give out the marginal calls while missing absolute stone dead ones.
 
Did not expect such a turn around tonight thought we may have had them 5 down. So this is f***ing great.

Haway england keep it pitched up and lets rattle these rabbits out tonight
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top