• The forum upgrades are now largely complete.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Inheritance Tax Penalty: who pays?

I talked to him at the time and it was impossible for him to get a mortgage to keep the house. I don't know all the details as the poor boy was fagged to death with it all so I didn't want to interrogate him.
That's why I said it could be deferred 5 years. Gives him time to join the workforce, then he can easily get a £150k mortgage for a £600k house. For a 23 year old to be in that financial situation is tremendous.
 

If the surviving sibling, say maybe in their eighties, has no other assets other than the house, is facing a bill of £80,000, the £80,000 has to be paid and they would likely have to sell the house to pay the £80,000.
Agreed they'd still have £445,000 remaining to buy a new house. Not bad at all, but a huge upheaval. All I suggested was a tweak to pay the £80,000 on their death rather than within six months of the first sibling's death.

Seems cruel when a tweak is all that is needed. Same tax will be paid, just later. I never claimed they will be practically homeless .
Aren’t there equity release schemes where you basically sell a share in the house against a future sale for a percentage of its value? I’ve no doubt there’ll be extortionate fees involved but if it means Great Aunt Mildred can stay in the house she shared with her brother for the past 87 years then that has to be a good thing? The rellies then pick the bones of what’s leftover after she’s pegged it and the house is sold while the company shelling out for her over the years take their cut.
 
Aren’t there equity release schemes where you basically sell a share in the house against a future sale for a percentage of its value? I’ve no doubt there’ll be extortionate fees involved but if it means Great Aunt Mildred can stay in the house she shared with her brother for the past 87 years then that has to be a good thing? The rellies then pick the bones of what’s leftover after she’s pegged it and the house is sold while the company shelling out for her over the years take their cut.
I reckon there are likely several ways around situations from changing the type of ownership of the house, to bank loans, to what you posted, I don't know all the ins and outs. I think one poster said the IHT could be deferred at a cost (?)

My initial example (post #35 from memory) was putting a sympathetic take on perhaps tweaking the IHT where paying the IHT was detrimental to the person who had to pay it.
 
My family should get 100% of what I've got left when I snuff it. .
Why though? They didn't earn it, you did.
Homeless from his home he grew up in and then having to find something cheaper further out.

Am I missing something here? Don't almost all young people / students do that?
I don't mind part of my estate being taxed when I eventually passed. I'll have benefited enough from tax avoidance with what I've accumulated, so when it's time to pass it on to family, I honestly don't mind the prospect of what I haven't spent myself having a cut taken for the good of wider society (theoretically, anyway).
They might look the gift horse in the mouth once you are gone though....
 
Last edited:
Aren’t there equity release schemes where you basically sell a share in the house against a future sale for a percentage of its value? I’ve no doubt there’ll be extortionate fees involved but if it means Great Aunt Mildred can stay in the house she shared with her brother for the past 87 years then that has to be a good thing? The rellies then pick the bones of what’s leftover after she’s pegged it and the house is sold while the company shelling out for her over the years take their cut.


on a very quick look and only out of interest, it looks like it has to be in place before the death (and a subsequent IHT bill) I am happy to be put right though.

I guess when the estate is valued you can't then go reducing the assets [value] by 'getting rid of stuff'.
 
Cos you mentioned it last time it was highly unlikely you would, oh and you'll be dead
You have just made this up.
Because you'll be dead. The person receiving the gift will be paying it. It's a victimless "crime".
The person paying the bill is the person who has died. The bill is calculated on the estate value at death, before any distributions, so it doesn’t make sense to suggest it’s the person who’s receiving the gift who pays it.
 
Last edited:
You have just made this up.

The person paying the bill is the person who has died. The bill is calculated on the estate value at death, before any distributions, so it doesn’t make sense to suggest it’s the person who’s receiving the gift who pays it.
Only if you are willfully ignoring the obvious.
 
So you made it up then.

The calculations are what they are so it's a tough one to argue against.

Not really, you said you weren't due any inheritance, then rambled on about ambition which suggests your current status is that you're below the limit.
 
Cos you mentioned it last time it was highly unlikely you would, oh and you'll be dead
Well, it’s not “bobbins”, but there you go. We can argue about what should and should not be taxed. I have explained the reality to you though.

I am not due any inheritance as far as I am aware and I do not need something to affect me to have an opinion on the matter. Perhaps I have some ambition to be in that bracket? Or does just make me greedy?
Not really, you said you weren't due any inheritance, then rambled on about ambition which suggests your current status is that you're below the limit.
You are reading things that aren't there.

IHT is anti-family and the current thresholds and rates are arbitrary. 40% on whatever's left if you get hit by a bus or killed by a short illness is very, very heavy. I think building some wealth to secure your family's future (and therefore less likely to be a burden on the state) is a noble venture that should be incentivised, not penalised. The current rules in this country do not do that for anyone but the very, very wealthy.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top