Mr.Thunders
Striker
I think in his case the more he watches the more evidence he collects to suit his preconceived, cemented views. Many fans do that for players they don't rate. Some criticism of Cattermole has been more than valid but the likes of Ernie and Sessions watch games to find fault in that player rather than just watch with an open mind and speak objectively.
Doubt he went to 19 games mind but nevermind.
I mean if a player really gave a 3/10 performance you'd likely never see him play again for some time,if not again.
As for mostly 5's.....